image copyrightGetty Images

In the 16th century, when the kingdom of Spain began to incorporate the territories that made up America, it began to draw lines to divide those spaces and then administer them.

One of those lines crossed the region of the Uyuni salt flat, in present-day Bolivia.

Almost five centuries later, the drawing of that line, with the borders of Bolivia already formed, continues to generate a border dispute between the inhabitants of Potosí and Oruro.

Currently, in the world there are about 150 border disputes over territories that are disputed between countries. Some of them are in Latin America, where the conflicts in the Essequibo region between Venezuela and Guyana stand out, with enormous oil wealth, or the San Andrés archipelago that generates disputes between Colombia and Nicaragua.

But there is more: the problems derived from arbitrary border lines not only occur between countries, but also within them.

For example, in Argentina about 86% of the boundaries between provinces lack definitive legal support.

In the midst of the boom in the exploitation of minerals such as lithium or copper deposits in the center of the country, these disputes are no longer matters that can be taken lightly.

"Many times the border lines within countries are not drawn with any scientific or legal rigor," Christian Ovando, an expert on border issues at the University of Tarapacá, in Chile, explains to BBC Mundo.

End of Most read

"Added to this is that old disputes that were already believed to have been resolved have resurfaced due to the discovery of hydrocarbons or lithium, as in the Argentine case. Furthermore, in many cases there is no defined legal framework that allows these disputes to be definitively resolved," he noted.

In Latin America there are dozens of cases in countries such as Colombia, Bolivia, Mexico, Brazil and Argentina, where the internal limits have not yet been clarified.

1. Punto Put, Mexico

All the news you need is on BBC World Service

Download it here

End of Ad app

In the province of Yucatán, in southern Mexico, a unique border phenomenon occurs: in the absence of a clear dividing line between the states of Quintana Roo, Campeche and Yucatán, the three share the same meeting point.

This place is known as Put Point. It is an abandoned construction where the different disputed dividing lines in this region converge. The conflict affects nearly 13,000 people who live in a territory of 240 square kilometers and who, in many cases, do not know with certainty which state they belong to.

The origin of this problem dates back about 120 years. In 1902, the then president Porfirio Díaz created the federal territory of Quintana Roo, but with a drawback: in the absence of natural geographical features, such as mountains or rivers, the territorial delimitation was not precisely defined.

For this reason, according to the country's historical records, a geographical commission was created in 1922 to solve the problem. It was then that a structure called Territorial Union Point (PUT) was built.

But, according to various experts, each state ended up locating the border coordinates according to their convenience: Campeche located it in a place called Rancho Put; Yucatán, near the PUT; and Quintana Roo, where the limit had originally been set in 1902.

This generated a series of disputed territories whose status is not clearly defined, causing many "stateless" people to lack adequate access to services such as health, education or the internet.

But dozens of square kilometers with important natural resources and economic wealth are also at stake.

"Many politicians come and promise that they will solve the problem. But they only want the votes, while we do not know which municipality we belong to or to which one we should claim our rights," explained Alejandro Álvarez, a resident of the area, to the newspaper El Informador de México.

Currently, the case is in the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, which will be the body in charge of determining the definitive limits of this area of ​​the country.

2. Oruro vs. Potosi, Bolivia

For many historians, such as the Mexican Arturo Escobar or the British John Lynch, the limits imposed by the Spanish during the colonial era were based on arbitrary decisions, without considering the communities that inhabited those territories.

A great example of this occurred in present-day Bolivia, especially in the Uyuni region, in the south of the country. During the colonial era, Spain delimited the area based on an administrative and economic vision - since Potosí was an enormous source of colonial wealth - rather than on the indigenous communities that inhabited it.

This division, later consolidated with the creation of the departments of Oruro and Potosí in the 19th century, has been the subject of various attempts to solve it through agrarian reforms. However, it still generates conflicts in today's Bolivia.

The dispute centers on 100 kilometers of border between the south of the department of Oruro and the north of Potosí, between the municipalities of Salinas de García Mendoza and Quillacas in Oruro and Coromas in Potosí, which includes a part of the salt flat.

In recent years, there have been serious disputes in that area over the control of agricultural areas of great productive value, especially for the cultivation of quinoa, as well as over the economic benefits associated with one of the main tourist destinations in the country: the Uyuni salt flat.

One of the most serious conflicts is that of Coroma and Quillacas, which have maintained strong disputes over the territories of Mount Pahua, rich in limestone, the main raw material for the production of cement.

In fact, between 2010 and 2012 there were violent clashes between inhabitants of both provinces over control of this resource.

Added to this is the claim of sectors of Oruro, based on historical records dating back to colonial times, which maintain that they have rights over a part of the salt flat, especially the one near the Tunupa volcano. In fact, in certain parts of Oruro the site is called the Tunupa salt flat.

Potosí, for its part, considers that this claim is unfounded, since the salt flat is entirely within its jurisdiction.

This dispute has not been able to be definitively resolved because, according to Bolivian legislation, internal border conflicts must be resolved through agreements or town meetings between the parties involved.

"In this dispute there are several elements that it shares with other disputes in the region, such as the valuation of quinoa and mining, but there is an extra element: the claim of indigenous communities," says Ovando.

"For this reason, its resolution, in addition to the technical aspects, is conditioned by the social consensus provided by the autonomous indigenous bases in conflict," he adds.

3. Argentina: copper and lithium

On November 5, an Argentine court decided to refer a dispute between the provinces of Salta and Catamarca, in the northwest, to the Supreme Court to determine which has the exploitation rights to an important lithium mine.

According to Esteban Alizzi, a geographer specialized in border issues at Conicet, the boundary problems in this area date back mainly to 1943, when the national territory of Los Andes was dissolved, which was distributed between the provinces of Jujuy, Salta and Catamarca.

"The problem worsened when mining activity expanded over two areas, the Salar de los Diablillos and the Salar del Hombre Muerto, where both Salta and Catamarca claim exploitation rights," Alizzi tells BBC Mundo.

The problem is that, when the Supreme Court of Justice was asked to resolve this dispute, the court considered that the jurisdiction corresponded to Congress.

Currently, about 86% of the border agreements in Argentina, where there are 23 provinces and one federal district, lack adequate legal support.

For many analysts, this situation is especially delicate in a country that is increasingly developing large-scale mining projects, as is the case between the provinces of La Rioja and San Juan, where the Vicuña and Josemaría projects are located.

There it is expected to extract nearly 390,000 tons of copper per year.

"I believe that all this highlights the importance of advancing the investigation and comparison of cases of border disputes between subnational units, since it is a relatively understudied topic, at least in the Argentine case," explains the expert.

"This type of analysis helps to understand the way in which government and management practices interact with historical and economic processes in the configuration of territories," he adds.

Discover more

Video

End of Video

Top news

"It bothers them to share the air they breathe with me": how the rise of the extreme right in Germany is affecting Latin American migrants

3 little-known border disputes within Latin American countries (and why some have escalated)

Miguel Ángel Félix Gallardo, the "Boss of Bosses" who revolutionized drug trafficking in Mexico by allying himself with Colombian cartels, dies at 80

Don't miss it

Most popular readings