Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni is facing the fallout from a public rebuke this week by Donald Trump over the pope, Iran and a defense deal with Israel. A rupture which began at the start of the war against Iran and which could serve the political interests of the head of Fratelli d'Italia in the run-up to the 2027 legislative elections.
Published on: 04/17/2026 - 5:07 p.m. Modified on: 04/17/2026 - 9:44 p.m.
To display this YouTube content, it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.
An extension in your browser appears to be blocking the loading of the video player. To be able to watch this content, you must disable or uninstall it.
It was on board a government plane, somewhere between Verona and Rome, that the President of the Italian Council Giorgia Meloni learned that American President Donald Trump considered her behavior "unacceptable". His collaborators had pointed out to him an interview given by the American president to Corriere della Sera, published on April 14. She read it. Then, according to the Italian daily's story, the far-right leader repeated a formula that she had already used that afternoon: "Being allies does not mean that there are no red lines, and it certainly does not mean being vassals or subjects."
In this interview, Donald Trump does not mince his words. "I'm shocked by her. I thought she had courage, but I was wrong."
Her grievances are twofold: Giorgia Meloni's refusal to support the war led by the United States against Iran, and her condemnation of the attacks made by the American president against Pope Leo XIV, which she herself described as "unacceptable".
“She is the one who is unacceptable,” tackled the American president, “because she does not care that Iran has a nuclear weapon and would blow up Italy in two minutes if it had the chance.”
Also read: Donald Trump, the Pope and Jesus Christ: religious hiccups that can be expensive
This dispute also comes against the backdrop of Rome's decision to suspend the renewal of a defense cooperation agreement with Israel. A choice announced Tuesday, which further fuels tensions.
The exchange with Donald Trump caused a shock wave in Italian political life, but not quite in the way that the American president might have wished.
Back at Palazzo Chigi, the official residence of the presidents of the Italian Council, late Tuesday afternoon, the government of Giorgia Meloni reacted quickly. Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani, also head of the center-right Forza Italia party, and Defense Minister Guido Crosetto post almost identical messages on social media, emphasizing Italy's national interest and dignity as an ally. “We are and remain strong supporters of Western unity and steadfast allies of the United States, but this unity is based on mutual loyalty, respect and honesty,” writes Antonio Tajani.
The next morning, the headlines reported a rare political consensus. The daily La Repubblica describes this sequence as a moment of Italian unity, presenting Giorgia Meloni's response as a "new Maginot line" against what it describes as "an unpredictable man occupying the White House". Il Giornale, on the right of the political spectrum, for its part welcomes a position which favors “Italy first”.
Also read: Giorgia Meloni, three years of optical stability
Suspension of defense agreement with Israel
Giorgia Meloni took another step highlighting this new direction. “Given the current situation, the government decides to suspend the automatic renewal of the defense agreement with Israel,” she announced on the sidelines of a wine event organized in Verona. An Italian diplomatic source confirms this suspension to Agence France-Presse (AFP), stating bluntly: "It would have been politically difficult to maintain it."
The agreement, approved by Israel in 2006 and renewed every five years, covers cooperation in the areas of defense industry, military training, research and development, and information technology.
This decision follows a sharp deterioration in bilateral relations. Tensions between the two countries escalated after the Italian government accused Israeli forces of firing warning shots at a convoy of Italian peacekeepers in Lebanon, damaging at least one vehicle.
Italy then summoned the Israeli ambassador in protest on April 8. In return, the Jewish state summoned the Italian ambassador, after the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Antonio Tajani, condemned, during a visit to Beirut, "unacceptable attacks" against Lebanese civilians.
If this suspension marks a clear break, its concrete impact could nevertheless prove limited. “The decision not to renew the defense cooperation agreement with Israel is of political importance, but its significance should not be exaggerated,” explains Daniele Amoroso, professor of international law at the University of Cagliari. “It is probably more symbolic than concrete.”
The bridge that did not hold
Until recently, Giorgia Meloni was by far Donald Trump's closest European ally. She was the only European leader to attend his inauguration in January 2025 and had since positioned herself as a transatlantic bridge. His political memoir “Io Sono Giorgia” (“I am Giorgia”), republished in English in 2025, even includes a foreword by Donald Trump.
For Mario Del Pero, professor of international history at Sciences Po Paris, the rupture was structurally inevitable. “It became politically untenable for Meloni to be associated with Trump,” he told France 24.
"He is extremely unpopular in Europe and in Italy. Being too close to him is the kiss of death for a European politician," he continues, citing the recent electoral defeat of Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban as an example not to follow. Indeed, for Mario Del Pero, the Hungarian leader's proximity to Donald Trump and the visit to Budapest by American Vice-President J. D. Vance a few days before the elections could have cost him additional votes.
According to the professor, the ambition to serve as a link between Washington and Brussels has always been an illusion: "On certain key issues, you have to side with one or the other. Italy signed the joint declaration on Greenland, then another on Iran. It is difficult to play the role of mediator."
See alsoDonald Trump and Giorgia Meloni, breakup time
As the legislative elections scheduled for 2027 approach, Mario Del Pero believes that the internal political logic which pushes us to distance ourselves from Donald Trump is obvious.
An analysis shared by Professor Amoroso. “Meloni distanced himself from Trump quite visibly, and his acerbic remarks were simply unprecedented,” he says, adding that these tensions reflect “a politically necessary readjustment,” rather than a fundamental change in foreign policy.
Italy's fundamental strategic priorities remain unchanged, he noted, highlighting its commitments to NATO, its support for Ukraine and its continued alignment with the European Union.
However, the political calculus has changed. “Polls suggest that Trump is deeply unpopular in Italy,” reports Daniele Amoroso. “In this context, (Meloni’s) distancing himself from Trump might be the least costly option.”
Ambiguity as a governance strategy
Italy has not been spared from Trump's tariffs, and the country last month refused permission for US bombers to land at a strategic air base in Sicily.
Italy has always maintained close ties with Iran, Mario Del Pero notes, and it continued to engage with Tehran after the 1979 Islamic Revolution, within the confines of Western sanctions and changing international tensions. Furthermore, he said, the conflict in the Middle East is a war "that Europe did not want, about which it was not consulted and about which it was not informed".
Vincenzo Susca, a lecturer in Italian politics at Paul-Valéry University in Montpellier, argues that the Meloni government achieved something historically unusual in Italy: an enduring alliance between the far right, the traditional right and Catholic Christian Democratic forces, held together by carefully orchestrated ambiguity.
As the 2027 legislative elections approach, this coalition will be essential to Giorgia Meloni's political survival. Preserving its internal balance will be essential if it hopes to remain in power.
On the issue of immigration, continues Vincenzo Susca, the government has maintained an "aggressive rhetoric", notably with the project of migrant camps in Albania, which has since failed, but little has changed in practice. Internationally, the same logic applies. “It’s a marketing-oriented image,” analyzes the expert, “designed to make the government appear moderate, particularly internationally, when it really is not.”
The need for ambiguity is structural, concludes Vincenzo Susca: Giorgia Meloni governs in a space suspended between European expectations and Trumpian impulses.
This article is an adaptation by Pauline Rouquette of the original paper in English available here.
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




