To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

First modification: 02/20/2026 - 17:24

Are social networks designed to generate an addiction comparable to that of cigarettes? A group of teenagers, school districts and state prosecutors in the United States believe so. That is why they took some of the largest technology companies in the world to court, in an unprecedented trial: Meta and Alphabet face direct accusations of having created deliberately addictive platforms for minors. What is really at stake and what can the consequences be? We analyze it with the experts in El Debate de France 24.

The case originated with the lawsuit of a 20-year-old girl who claims that she became addicted to social media when she was a minor and that features such as “infinite scroll” aggravated her depression and led her to have suicidal thoughts.

Snapchat and TikTok reached a confidential settlement with her, but the process continues against Instagram and YouTube.

The trial, in which Mark Zuckerberg even testified, seeks to determine whether companies like Meta and Alphabet deliberately designed addictive platforms for minors and what responsibility they have for the effects on their mental health.

Read alsoZuckerberg admits flaws in historic trial for social media addiction in Los Angeles

In this context, in El Debate de France 24 we ask ourselves: Do big technology companies design social networks to cause addiction? How dangerous can they be for minors?

Laura Coronado, lawyer and specialist in regulation and digital culture, who has participated in the “I am Digital” program with Meta and has accompanied the presentation of Instagram accounts for teenagers, maintains that social networks are not addictive in themselves, but rather communication tools.

"Social networks occupy the place that we give them as a society. Yes, there is a real problem in the time we spend in front of devices, both adults and children, but we must focus on digital literacy," he says.

In addition, it warns that “they are not a digital nanny nor should they be confused with a parenting substitute.”

For his part, Facundo Bianco, co-founder of Bienestar Digital and contributor to the book 'Caring for childhood in the digital age', highlights the need for a comprehensive approach.

“It is necessary to provide answers in an interdisciplinary manner, with the focus on children and adolescents,” he points out.

He also highlights that the public debate is progress: “Consequences are beginning to be seen in the development, self-esteem and ability to concentrate of children and adolescents, something that we adults also observe from our own experience.”

The ethical axis runs through the discussion and the current legal issue: if algorithms are designed as part of the business model to maximize consumption time, where does the responsibility lie, on companies, on the State or on parents, and is the comparison with cigarette addiction valid?

For experts, the minimum age for access to platforms and the role of families in digital support are also on the table.

In the midst of this unprecedented trial, the discussion goes beyond an individual case: it puts the business model of big technology companies under the microscope and forces us to rethink the limits, responsibilities and risks of the digital ecosystem in which children and adolescents grow up.

From Mexico and Buenos Aires they join us in El Debate:

📲Subscribe here to the France 24 channel on WhatsApp and access all the content to understand what is happening in the world.

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.