image copyrightGetty Images

US Vice President JD Vance caused a stir in Washington on Wednesday by directly blaming the war with Iran for his party's defeat in the midterm elections, in what was widely interpreted as an attempt to distance himself from President Donald Trump ahead of a possible run for the White House in 2028.

In a carefully crafted 600-word statement published on X, Vance acknowledged that Trump's 2024 voters had abandoned the Republicans in the midterm elections.

"The reason we lost is the war," he wrote. "The president himself said it last night."

In interviews late Tuesday and Wednesday, Trump defended the war but acknowledged that it influenced Democrats to wrest control of the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate.

Vance's stance on the war in Iran is an open secret in Washington. While he has repeatedly backed the conflict since the United States and Israel attacked Tehran in February, he has reportedly expressed his opposition in private meetings with government officials.

But those disagreements had been kept hidden from the public, until now.

Hours after Trump and his party suffered a tough election defeat, Vance made it clear that he considered the decision to go to war a clear political mistake.

"If you want to argue that it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next six years was worth it, do it. Argue that it was a price worth paying. Whether you agree or not, at least it's honest," Vance said.

End of Most read

All the news you need is on BBC World Service

Download it here

End of Ad app

It was a shocking statement, and without recent precedent: it is difficult to remember a similar moment in recent American political history in which a sitting vice president broke so sharply with the president on a key foreign policy issue.

Then came an even bigger surprise: Trump, who often demands unwavering loyalty from his top advisers, agreed with Vance that the midterm elections were "largely" decided by war. He added that he would do it again if he had to choose.

It was an early sign that Trump, who highly values ​​the loyalty of his advisers, might steer clear of Vance if he decides to launch a presidential campaign.

"I know what you think about it. I think it was good," Trump told reporters when asked about Vance's post blaming the war. "I already knew it when I started it, and we stopped them from having a nuclear weapon, and they never will."

Vance's statement seemed like "a way to distance himself from Trump," said Daniel Byman, a foreign policy expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

delicate balance

Drawing contrasts with Trump will be a delicate balancing act if Vance seeks the presidency, Byman added.

That balance was evident in Vance's post. The vice president did not mention Trump by name and attributed much of his analysis of the election results to anonymous pollsters.

image source, Reuters

"Vance tested the waters to see what he could do," Republican strategist Ashley Davis told the BBC.

Beyond criticism of the war with Iran, Vance also offered a political roadmap that could preview a possible presidential campaign. He summarized the party's strategy for winning back voters in a four-point plan: "1: End the war; 2: Focus on the cost of living and inflation; 3: Put America first; 4: Change our relationship with Israel."

The list summed up much of Vance's worldview since he burst onto the national political scene, and seemed like the central plot of a future campaign speech.

The BBC has contacted Vance's office for comment.

Of course, the next presidential election is still two years away. Vance is expected to run, but he has not made an official decision and his advisers insist he is still mulling it over.

The extent to which Vance distanced himself from Trump is also a matter of debate. According to The New York Times, Vance showed the message to Trump before posting it online.

For his part, Trump could change his mind and make clear that he will not tolerate any dissent from Vance or anyone else.

The president has been cagey about who he would support to succeed him as the Republican presidential candidate in 2028. Trump has praised Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio on several occasions, but has not said when or if he would give his endorsement.

The president seems to enjoy the guessing game about who he would support to continue his political movement, even though in the past he has considered the idea of ​​continuing for a third term (which is prohibited by the United States Constitution).

Vance's missive in the midterm elections may not turn out to be as significant in the end. Or perhaps it was the starting signal for the 2028 race and the battle for the Republican Party after the Trump era.

*Nardine Saad contributed information.

End of content

This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.

Discover more

Video

End of Video

Top news

"Trump's defeat limits his internal power, but not necessarily his influence in the world"

5 reasons that explain the overwhelming defeat of the Republican Party in the US midterm elections.

'This is a disaster': Outraged Republicans blame Trump for resounding defeat in midterm elections

Don't miss it

Most popular readings