Credit, Anadolu via Getty Images

Samraa Luqman has always been a Democrat. But she proudly voted for Donald Trump's reelection to the American Presidency in 2024.

A single issue motivated his vote on that occasion. And this same factor now defines his choice in this week's midterm elections in the United States (known as midterms, in English).

"It's Gaza or nothing," the Yemeni-American told BBC World Service's The Global Story radio program.

"If you're not good about Gaza, Israel and Palestine, we don't need you in power and we don't need to vote for you, no matter what your party affiliation."

Angered by American support for Israel, traditional Democratic Party voters like Luqman helped build the Republican Party's victory in the crucial swing state of Michigan in 2024.

Now, similar concerns are mobilizing voters on both sides of the debate in one of the most fierce disputes in this year's elections.

The fight over Michigan's open seat in the US Senate is key to determining which party will control the country's Congress for the remainder of Donald Trump's term.

Democrats need to keep this seat. Republicans need the turnaround. And as Election Day approaches, the decision seems like a coin toss.

End of Most read

On one side is the democratic doctor Abdul El-Sayed. If elected this Tuesday (3/11), he will become the first Muslim senator in the United States.

His opponent is Republican Mike Rogers, a former FBI agent. He was a member of the United States House of Representatives for 14 years.

Midterms typically focus on domestic issues such as the economy and cost of living. But the war in Gaza has become almost a litmus test for Michigan voters.

For different reasons, both candidates highlighted American spending on the conflict. According to the Costs of War project at Brown University in Rhode Island (USA), these expenses exceeded US$31 billion (around R$169 billion) in the first two years.

Supported by Trump, Rogers claims that military aid to Israel's operation following the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023 is a national security issue for the United States.

El-Sayed, an avowed progressive, has repeatedly denounced the use of American tax money to finance what he describes as genocide — an accusation that Israel vehemently rejects.

In the primary elections that led to his nomination as the Democratic Party candidate for Senate in the State of Michigan, El-Sayed narrowly defeated his moderate opponent Haley Stevens, a staunch defender of Israel.

But two days before polls opened this Tuesday (11/3), Stevens surprised his fellow Democrats by publicly supporting Rogers. She calls the dispute between candidates from both parties a battle for the "conscience of the Senate" and a referendum on "hate."

Stevens' unexpected support came after an intense campaign, criticized for frequent Islamophobic and anti-Semitic attacks. And it pushed latent ideological tensions to the limit.

Credit, AFP via Getty Images

Michigan is home to the highest percentage of Arab-Americans of any state in the country. And also a considerable population of Jewish voters, strong supporters of Israel.

Historically, the two communities have formed a key pillar of Democrats. But, in 2024, the situation changed.

Disappointed with Democratic foreign policy toward the Middle East, Arab and Muslim voters organized a campaign to refuse their support for the party.

And, when the presidential candidacy passed to then-Vice President Kamala Harris, with her promises of continuity, voters like Luqman felt betrayed.

"I was furious because I was a lifelong Democrat," she says, "and it wasn't just because they didn't say the word 'ceasefire' or try to halt the genocide."

"It was specifically because they stood their ground and said, 'We did nothing wrong. We will continue with our policies.'"

In response, Luqman joined the wave of Muslim voters in support of Trump.

"I didn't just vote," according to her. “I campaigned for him.”

Now, Luqman considers herself a Republican, but enthusiastically supports El-Sayed for Senate.

Credit, Bloomberg via Getty Images

Credit, Getty Images

Another Arab-American voter, Amer Zahar, says that it took the warning of the 2024 election for the Democratic Party to adopt a pro-Palestinian candidate like El-Sayed.

"The Democratic Party doesn't always listen to me, and I don't think they always listen to our community," he said.

"We needed to cause a revolution in the Democratic Party and that's what we did in 2024... So, after that revolution and the victory of good candidates regarding Palestine, the party became much more than a home for us."

In Michigan, the Democratic Party may have addressed the concerns of many Arab-American voters. But now, another group is expressing its fear of being abandoned.

Some voters question El-Sayed's ability to protect the Jewish community in a time of crisis.

After a violent attack on the Temple Israel synagogue in Michigan in March, the candidate said that "hurt people hurt other people." The person responsible for the attack had lost relatives in an Israeli airstrike in Lebanon.

El-Sayed later apologized. He said he was not trying to justify the attack, but his statement did not completely defuse tensions.

“That really was a punch in the gut,” Michigan Board of Rabbis President Aaron Starr said. He has publicly stated that he will not vote for El-Sayed.

"The majority of our community voted Democrat and now feel that the language and actions of members of the Democratic Party — not all, but certain Democratic Party candidates — are putting our safety at risk," Starr told the BBC World Service.

As some of Michigan's Muslim Democrats did in 2024, there are staunch Jewish Democrats who will now vote for the Republican candidate, or abstain from voting.

"I'm a Democrat, but first and foremost I need to believe that the person I'm voting for respects me, my politics and my existence," said attorney and University of Michigan board member Jordan Acker.

He has known El-Sayed for 20 years and they studied at university together. But Acker isn't sure he'll vote for his former classmate.

"In Abdul's worldview, it seems that Jews are acceptable as individuals. Jews are not acceptable as a people. And to me, that is extremely troubling."

At the same time, Rogers has been trying to win over the state's Jewish voters by showing that he is a strong friend of Israel. And he has also called El-Sayed “anti-Jewish”.

Critics accuse Rogers of fueling Islamophobia by trying to label his opponent as a sympathizer of Islamic extremism.

Rogers and Trump accused El-Sayed, whose family immigrated from Egypt, of maintaining ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. El-Sayed has repeatedly expressed his rejection and denied any connection with the group.

For a significant portion of the electorate, the heated U.S. Senate campaign exacerbated not only partisan divisions but also ethnic and racial tensions. But Jewish voter David Freund, a supporter of El-Sayed, isn't too worried about the long-term effects.

"Security for all minorities depends on defending all minorities," according to him.

“Jewish security will not be preserved as a separate category called ‘Jewish security.’ It is part of the overall question about the democratic rights of all people.”

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

What are the US midterm elections and why could they seal Trump's future?

The identity crisis that threatens Democrats' ambition in a crucial election for Trump

Why US and Israeli elections have global consequences

On the eve of the Congressional election, how is the US economy doing under Trump's command?

How global conflicts became a headache for Trump in the US midterm elections

4 points from Trump's speech at an election event: '$5,000 for every American' and the war in Iran will end 'after the election'

Top news

Daughter of Brazilian parents was co-pilot of the plane that crashed in Florida and left 9 people dead; what is known

Nine people die in plane crash in Florida; who were the victims

US elections: how support for Israel and the war in Gaza affect the Senate race

read more

Most clicked