The differences between the judges of the Supreme Court of the United States have begun to move away from the realm of discretion and privacy that have always characterized relationships between judges. As they address decisions such as abortion, transgender rights, immigration policies, civil rights or limits on presidential power, those dissents have been increasingly public and sharp. What is happening in the highest American court?
First modification: 04/19/2026 - 05:37
It was an apparently unusual situation. A judge, Sonia Sotomayor (liberal, nominated by Barack Obama in 2009, the third woman on the Court and the first of Hispanic origin) weeks ago criticized Justice Brett Kavanaugh, nominated by Trump, a member of the conservative majority.
The questions revolved around his opinion in a judicial decision of the Court linked to a case on the immigration policies of the White House and the Trump Administration, and his promised crusade of mass deportations.
During an event in the state of Kansas, Sotomayor threw barbs at her colleague that were not only related to her judicial opinion or legal criteria within the framework of the Constitution and civil rights, but also struck a personal chord, by mentioning Kavanaugh's family and personal history.
Critics questioned Kavanaugh's opinion in a case called "Noem v. Vasquez Perdomo," from September 2025, in which the Court upheld the legality of immigration detentions based on factors such as racial profiling and employment in low-wage jobs.
Although Sotomayor did not mention Kavanaugh, the reference and criticism was unequivocal: Kavanaugh — who came to the Court after the retirement of Anthony Kennedy — was the only member of the majority who explained his vote.
"This is coming from someone whose parents were professionals. And he probably doesn't know anyone who works hourly or piecework like me," Sotomayor slipped.
Also read EE. USA: Supreme Court limits action by federal judges against Trump orders
A comment that referred to the origins and training within a family of professionals, with greater privileges. Sotomayor added that some people “can't understand our experiences, even when you tell them.”
Sotomayor's criticism of Kavanaugh exposed the latest and continuing frictions and divisions within the nation's highest judicial body. Tensions that have their origin in the different visions about the direction of the Court under the direction of its president, John Roberts, and the recent decisions in high-profile cases.
The questions were followed by a rare public apology: "In a recent appearance at the University of Kansas School of Law, I addressed a disagreement with one of my colleagues in a previous case, but I made inappropriate comments. I regret my hurtful comments," Sotomayor said in a statement released by the Court, adding: "I have already apologized to my colleague."
Public tensions and friction show the crack
Kavanaugh is one of six conservative justices on the Court, which currently has a 6-3 makeup, where progressives are in the minority. He had previously supported the majority decision on the powers of immigration authorities to carry out indiscriminate raids in California.
The so-called conservative block or wing of the Court is also made up of its president John Roberts, and the justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett.
Sotomayor, meanwhile, is the senior justice in the liberal minority, all women, rounded out by Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
The magistrates (Associated Justices, in English) can argue their votes or legal criteria, or even express their disagreements in rulings or sentences through writings characterized by a precise tone, attached to the individual interpretation of the Constitution and the laws, but also argumentative, where they explain their conclusions.
They also have the right or prerogative to express their dissent, when their vote is not part of the majority or is in disagreement with the final decision, through writings called 'dissents', which raise challenges, opposing ideas, different interpretations, in an adversarial narrative or contrary to the majority, generally cordial, free of personal attacks.
But recently these differences or criticisms have become more personal and public.
Is tradition being broken?
Historically, the justices of the Supreme Court of Justice of the United States have sought to exercise their functions under a traditional culture and standards, which have their maximum expression in fundamental values or principles such as judicial independence, impartiality and integrity.
Read alsoDirect to… Washington and the recent decisions of the Supreme Court of Justice
They are at the top of the hierarchy and preside over higher levels of the judicial system, such as the federal and appellate courts.
Traditionally, they maintain a low profile and tend to avoid the public spotlight or controversy, they avoid making statements outside their duties, and although they may sometimes share their reasoning in academic or institutional settings, they rarely air their differences in a bitter or confrontational manner.
Justice Kentanji Brown – the first African-American woman on the Court and nominated by former President Barack Obama – has questioned her colleagues in the conservative bloc for what she has characterized as the “abuse” of the motions included in the so-called “emergency file”, to judge on matters that lower courts can deal with.
These requests, the majority used in an exacerbated manner by the Administration of President Donald Trump, allow requests to be processed urgently or precautionary measures to be issued that require rapid action, usually outside the schedule of oral hearings, which usually take - if the causes are admitted - several months.
Justice Clarence Thomas, the first African-American on the Court - and under frequent scrutiny for allegations of receiving gifts and perks from conservative figures and millionaires, such as Republican magnate Harlan Crow - has questioned the progressive wing of the Court.
Thomas has characterized his colleagues' bloc as an "existential threat" to the country's founding principles and the ideas of the framers of the Constitution.
“Progressivism seeks to replace the fundamental principles of the Declaration of Independence and, therefore, our form of government,” he stated in a speech at the University of Texas School of Law in Austin, Texas, on April 16.
Thomas — whose Senate confirmation in 1991 was marred by a trial alleging sexual abuse against attorney Anita Hill — has been accused of misconduct for failing to declare gifts and presents from figures like Crow.
The investigative outlet ProPublica has published extensive reports since 2023, revealing the failure to declare high-value gifts, trips and real estate transactions.
Read alsoSupremo examines Trump's plan to limit birthright citizenship: what do the Constitution and the decree say?
For more than two decades, Thomas reportedly accepted luxury vacations, including flights on Crow's private jet and trips on his superyacht, in violation of federal disclosure laws, which seek to prevent conflicts of interest. Thomas later amended his statements to include the trips and gifts.
Judge Amy Coney Barrett has also criticized her colleague Brown in her sentencing writings. In 2025 he questioned her for her "extreme" dissidence and with "social connotations", in a case related to citizenship by birthright.
Coney Barrett—a Trump nominee—accused Brown of “misinterpreting” the Constitution and “overstepping his judicial powers.” He also argued that his vision of the Executive power is erroneous and recalled “that judges, not just the president, are subject to the law.”
Read alsoErnesto Calvo: 'The Supreme Court has expanded the powers of Donald Trump'
Relations between judges, traditionally characterized by decorum, mutual respect and discretion, seem to have begun to show fractures and differences beyond the legal field, as the same issues that divide public opinion and political factors in the United States reach their offices.
With Reuters, AP, AFP, EFE and local media
Related keywords
The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.




