As Donald Trump's famous Peace Council meets for the very first time on Thursday, France 24 spoke with historian and UN specialist Alanna O'Malley. She judges that this body seeks to further institutionalize American power on a global scale under the leadership of Donald Trump. She sees it as a tool.
Published on: 02/19/2026 - 2:25 p.m.
Initially created to oversee the ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, as well as the future reconstruction of the devastated Palestinian territory, Donald Trump's Peace Council actually has a much broader mandate. According to its founding charter, signed at the annual meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos in January, this new body is responsible for promoting peace, stability and “reliable and lawful governance” throughout the world.
A mission which, specifies its preamble, requires "the courage to move away from approaches and institutions which have too often failed". It is therefore not surprising that some countries saw this as a use by the president of the council, Donald Trump himself, of this structure to marginalize the UN, already in difficulty, in favor of his own multilateral body composed of hand-picked members and led by an executive also chosen by him.
As a reminder, around twenty countries have signed the founding charter, which offers permanent membership to States ready to pay a billion dollars into its coffers.
As for the council logo, it was revealed during the signing. It is a globe surrounded by gold, tilted so as to place it over North America, at the center of the world.
Furthermore, the creation of this council comes at a delicate moment. In February, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warned that the world body was facing "imminent financial collapse" due to arrears in contributions and budget cuts.
Also read: Trump's Peace Council: what we know about the inaugural meeting in Washington
That includes nearly $4 billion still owed by the United States – more than 95% of the UN's regular budget arrears, according to officials. Even if the American authorities affirm that Washington will soon begin to settle its debts.
Historian and United Nations specialist Alanna O’Malley heads the department of history of wealth and globalization at Erasmus University in Rotterdam. She believes that the creation of Donald Trump's Peace Council, which above all obeys a "MAGA agenda", must lead to a start in UN member states summoned to reform the United Nations which has been losing momentum for years.
France 24: It is difficult not to notice that this expansion of the role of the Peace Council comes at a time when the UN claims to be facing funding difficulties, partly due to American arrears. To what extent can we see in this the desire of the Trump administration to redirect its resources towards an organ placed under its control?
Alanna O’Malley: The more time we devote to the creation of an alternative institution like the Peace Council, the more we reduce the energy – financial, manpower, intellectual input devoted to the UN. In this regard, this constitutes a fundamental challenge for the functioning of the United Nations, and for the exercise of American power within it, due to its divergence from this institution.
It must be remembered that the UN has been losing momentum for quite a long time now, especially over the last five years. Because the institution seems reluctant or incapable of responding quickly to major international crises, notably the Russian aggression against Ukraine and the crisis in Gaza.
As this happens, the reputation of the UN declines and states feel less obliged to pay their obligatory contributions, as the institution loses its value in their eyes. The UN is in a very difficult financial situation, as many members have simply not paid their dues. Its financial difficulties reduce its effectiveness, which makes the situation even worse. This creates a vicious cycle.
However, I do not necessarily see the Peace Council as a direct response to the UN crisis. Its genesis is different: it is part of the MAGA (Make America Great AGain) program in terms of foreign policy. It is about asserting American power in the world, in response to Russian aggression and the rise of China's political power.
Initially, this institution was proposed as part of the peace agreement for Gaza, approved by the United Nations Security Council. At the time, it seemed that it would be limited to this crisis, and not intended to become a permanent structure dealing with other crises. We now see that there has been an American effort to institutionally embed the global power of the United States in an organization that more directly serves its interests.
The other thing to consider is that there is now a return to 19th century ideas about spheres of influence, certainly Russia and China see the world that way. I therefore think that this institution is the expression of the United States' turnaround towards thinking about spheres of influence. And we are currently seeing this type of “hemispheric” rhetoric emanating largely from the Trump administration.
Also read: How Trump turned the world upside down with his obsession with the Western Hemisphere
Finally, this Peace Council also appears to be a reflection of Trump’s ego. The terms of operation provide that he would be president for life and would have a right of veto over all major decisions. This is the way for him to guarantee himself a position of supremacy in world affairs, even after leaving office as president of the United States. It is largely a personal project, which limits its credibility.
What room for maneuver remains then for any reform aimed at revitalizing the UN and restoring its legitimacy and relevance?
It should be kept in mind that the UN's popularity and power have ebbed and flowed over time. This is not the first crisis in 81 years, and it will not be the last. The UN has 193 members, 192 excluding the United States, and many of these other countries, including large European states such as France, the United Kingdom and Germany, as well as major players in the Global South, such as South Africa, India, Brazil and Indonesia, remain extremely committed to it. They continue to invest in preserving its values, principles, institutions and systems.
When great powers turn away from an institution, it can create a vacuum and more room for maneuver for other states. It is imperative that these countries clearly commit to UN reform.
We have seen countries defend the United Nations, saying they will not be part of the Peace Council, but we have yet to see countries take that step and actually commit to reforming the UN. There is an ongoing campaign around Article 109 of the UN Charter, which provides for the holding of a charter review conference every ten years. But this has never happened since 1945.
What reforms would you like to see emerge from this conference, if it were to take place?
I would like to see more power given to the General Assembly rather than the Security Council. Over the past ten years, the Assembly has shown more dynamism. Historically it is the most interesting form of the UN on a political level.
It constitutes the best barometer of the international community on any issue. This became very clear in relation to Gaza, where you had these overwhelming votes in favor of resolutions on the Gaza crisis and condemning Israel's military action.
The General Assembly also reflects new political trends. One of these has been the rejection by many countries in the Global South of European calls for resolutions on Ukraine, reflecting a growing North-South divide.
There have been numerous appeals to try to do more in the General Assembly, as the Security Council is essentially deadlocked. This is truly the taboo subject in any discussion of UN reform. Because any reform of the United Nations charter must be approved by the five permanent members of the Security Council.
The question is therefore how to pass a reform proposal while satisfying the five permanent members. We must think about a reform of the institution which does not dilute their power.
Is the Peace Council a response from the Trump administration to the growing diplomatic power of the Global South at the UN?
The countries of the Global South have had a majority in the General Assembly since 1960. They have used the institution to advance their interests, despite strong opposition from the West, for a long time.
The UN is often described as an exclusively Western instrument, but in reality it has always been the scene of contestation of the liberal world order. It is in this context that we must consider the action of the countries of the Global South.
Also readPanama Canal: where the Sino-American conflict is playing out in Latin America
The United States has at times been frustrated by this dynamic, as these agenda-shaping efforts limit American influence. The creation of the Peace Council is therefore perhaps a response to the growing influence of the countries of the Global South.
But to a large extent, the United States remains a major global partner and has different regional relationships with states in Latin America, Asia, Southeast Asia, and Africa. So I'm not sure the influence of the Global South is such a surprise to the United States. The main difficulty for Washington concerns Israel, a subject on which the United States has most often used its veto power in the Security Council.
It is more likely that the Peace Council was created primarily for other reasons, to institutionalize power under Donald Trump, rather than to sustainably consolidate the position of the United States in the world. This decision follows a deeply MAGA agenda.
This interview was adapted from English by Bahar Makooi. Find it in its original version here.
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




