Paris (France) (AFP) – The anti-immigrant conspiracy theory of the “great replacement”, returned to the heart of debates after the racist attack in Trappes, cannot claim scientific validation, researchers point out about this discourse regularly brandished by the far right.

Published on: 03/11/2026 - 21:13

In response to the racist attack in Yvelines, which cost the life of a 26-year-old black Frenchman on October 23 and left seven injured, environmentalist parliamentarians tabled bills on Friday to make illegal comments that invoke in particular "the replacement of one population by another".

This attack also fueled a flood of invective in the Assembly last week. Aurore Bergé, minister responsible for the fight against discrimination, was booed for having invoked "freedom of expression" in September on the subject of the "great replacement", which she said she was "fighting" elsewhere.

This theory supposes an alleged replacement on its territory of a white, European and Christian people by an immigrant population, mainly Muslim.

From the president of the National Front Jean-Marie Le Pen in 2014 to the vice-president of the RN Jordan Bardella in 2021, from Eric Zemmour (Reconquête!) and Marion Maréchal (Identité Libertés) to the LR candidate for the 2022 presidential election Valérie Pécresse, this conspiracy theory regularly comes up in the political debate.

Formulated in 2011 by the writer Renaud Camus, the notion of "great replacement" evokes a "population change" in "almost at once, in a generation", the result of a conspiracy by the elites.

The French writer, convicted several times for provoking hatred, did not invent anything: the idea has its roots in anti-Semitic, racist and xenophobic writings from the end of the 19th century.

Not “an overwhelm”

In 1893, the nationalist writer Maurice Barrès spoke of "the submersion, the disappearance of our civilization, all linked to the immigration... of Belgians", François Héran, honorary professor at the Collège de France (Migrations and Societies chair), reminded AFP.

This fear then matured "for decades on the margins of right-wing radicalism", underlines the historian Nicolas Lebourg.

After 1945, former Nazis and collaborationists developed the idea of ​​the destruction of Europe by a "Jewish plot" which organized the "importation" of African and Asian populations.

After the attacks of September 11, 2001, the theory refocused on racist and Islamophobic motives.

For Renaud Camus, everyone can make an empirical observation of this “replacement” accelerated by North African, sub-Saharan African and Muslim immigrants, just by “opening their eyes”.

His theory is not based on any scientific basis or data, underline experts interviewed by AFP.

From 3.7% in 1921, the share of immigrants of all origins (people residing in France born foreigners abroad) in the total population gradually rose to 7.4% in 1975, before remaining stable until 1999, then climbing to 11.6% in 2025, or 7.97 million people (including 3.92 million African immigrants), according to INSEE. That’s an increase of 50% over the last 25 years.

Certainly "significant", this increase "is in no way an overwhelm - an increase of 133,000 per year on average", explains Patrick Weil, emeritus research director at the CNRS, in his book "On Immigration in France" (2026).

Brewing

In France, "immigration, relative to its population, is not significant, neither in flow nor in stock, compared to other OECD countries", adds Jean-Christophe Dumont, head of the organization's International Migration Division, to AFP.

“The immigration rate – the number of people having the right to settle in France in 2024, compared to the entire population – is 0.45% for France, compared to an average for OECD countries of 0.81%,” he specifies.

The data also undermines the idea, hammered out by Eric Zemmour, of very high fertility among immigrant women from the Maghreb and sub-Saharan Africa.

In reality, if their "final fertility" is higher than that of the "majority population" (1.87 children per woman), it is close to it from the first generation of descendants in France, indicates a recent study by the National Institute of Demographic Studies (INED) covering 2019-2020.

Their fertility rate goes from 2.84 children per woman for immigrants from sub-Saharan Africa to 2.11 for their daughters, and from 2.80 to 1.91 for those from the Maghreb, according to this work.

Faced with those who assure that a demographic and cultural "replacement" would nevertheless take place via mixed unions, demographers explain that there is no eviction of one population by another but a significant mixing.

At the end of this mixing, the descendants of immigrants are "much more integrated into French society than first-generation immigrants", as INED notes.

Researchers are also concerned to see two categories of population opposed, one called "native", the other "of non-European origin". According to this logic, to what degree of ancestry without an immigrant ancestor would one have to go back to be considered fully French?, they ask.

ggy/alu/st

© 2026 AFP

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.