Credit, Reuters
With his re-election, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT) will have the chance to shape a new composition of forces in the Federal Supreme Court (STF), a Court that is deeply divided after the Banco Master scandal, as highlighted by law professors interviewed by BBC News Brasil.
The PT member, however, must face unprecedented difficulties in approving his chosen ones in the Senate. The House will have a Bolsonarist majority from February onwards - of the 81 senators, 44 are linked to this political field. In April of this year, Lula suffered a historic defeat in the Senate when Jorge Messias' name was rejected in the House.
Lula will be entitled to a significant number of nominations, although it is not yet clear how many there will be. This number will depend on uncertain factors, such as possible impeachment proceedings against members of the Court — a flag defended by a large number of the Bolsonaro senators elected to the new legislature.
In contrast, the STF can remain without renewal for nine years, between mid-2033 and 2042, a period in which there is no provision for any compulsory retirement of its members (read more below).
In addition to the vacancy opened with the departure of Luís Roberto Barroso in 2025, three more ministers will leave the Court because they will reach the age limit of 75 years: Luiz Fux (April 2028), Cármen Lúcia (April 2029) and Gilmar Mendes (December 30, 2030).
The nomination for Mendes's vacancy, however, could end up being left to the next president, as his mandatory retirement will be in the final days of the next term — unless he anticipates his departure.
Balance of forces within the Supreme
Experts point out that, at the moment, there are two wings in the STF: on the one hand, ministers Kássio Nunes Marques, André Mendonça and Luiz Fux. On the other, Alexandre de Moraes, Gilmar Mendes, Flávio Dino and Cristiano Zanin.
Among the two groups are Edson Fachin, Cármen Lúcia and Dias Toffoli. The three are seen as ministers who can oscillate between poles, depending on the issue being voted on.
End of Most read
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
The entry of new ministers, therefore, will reorganize the balance of power in the Court, notes Wallace Corbo, professor of Law at Fundação Getúlio Vargas (FGV) in Rio de Janeiro.
The appointment, however, is not a guarantee of alignment with the president who made the appointment — Fux, for example, today converges more with the ministers appointed by Bolsonaro, although he was chosen by former president Dilma Rousseff in 2011.
Despite the prospect of many nominations, Lula will face a major challenge in approving his nominees in a Senate with an opposition majority.
For Corbo, the president will be forced to change the profile of his choices in the fourth term, no longer nominating names close to him, as he did in the current government with Zanin and Dino. Clearly progressive jurists must also suffer greater resistance, he emphasizes.
As of February 2027, the Bolsonarist camp will have 44 of the 81 senators, according to a survey carried out by political scientist and researcher at the Institute of Social Sciences at the University of Lisbon, Beatriz Rey, sent to BBC News Brasil.
The number considers the future PL bench (29 senators), as well as members of other parties aligned with Bolsonarism, such as senators Damares Alves (Republicanos-DF) and Tereza Cristina (PP-MS) and the elected senator Deltan Dallagnol (Novo-PR).
To become a minister of the Supreme Court, a nominee must have his name approved by a majority in the Senate's Justice Constitution Commission (CCJ) and then be validated by an absolute majority in the Plenary. In other words, it needs to be approved by at least 41 senators.
"Lula will need to dialogue and find names that maintain some consensus with Congress, which is clearly on the right", also states Ingrid Dantas, researcher at the Center for Comparative Constitutional Studies at the University of Brasília (UnB).
If you don't do this, Dantas highlights, you could end up in a scenario similar to that of Argentine president Javier Milei. The country's Supreme Court, made up of just five ministers, has two vacancies open. Milei made two nominations in 2024, but they were blocked in April of the following year — and remain empty to date.
Even before the Bolsonarists expanded their bench in this election, Lula already had a nominee rejected, when the Senate blocked the choice of the Union's attorney general, Jorge Messias, to fill Barroso's old vacancy — the rejection of a name to the STF had not happened for more than a century.
As the difficulty in the next term will be even greater, there is great expectation that the president will try to approve again a nominee for Barroso's vacancy later this year, before taking office for his fourth term.
Lula even publicly declared, in May this year, that he would nominate Messias again, but they have been under pressure to choose another name.
Rodrigo Pacheco is the favorite of the president of the Senate, Davi Alcolumbre (União-AP). Former senator and current minister of the Federal Audit Court (TCU), Pacheco is an ally of Alcolumbre.
Twice president of the Senate, Pacheco is seen as a name that would be easier to be approved by the House.
Nomination of a woman to the Supreme Court
Progressive groups, in turn, have been pushing for the choice of a woman's name. The appointment of a jurist, preferably black, would be unprecedented in history.
For Wallace Corbo, from FGV, "it would be very positive" if Lula nominated a woman, especially a black woman. In his view, the most favorable time to approve an appointment with this profile would be before the new Congress takes office. Still, Corbo recognizes that, even with the current composition, this can be a challenge.
"The election, as much as it strengthened President Lula and placed Centrão in a posture of self-defense in relation to the upcoming Bolsonarism, did not change the fact that the political scenario continues to be very difficult for the appointment of an outsider. And the truth is that black people, women, continue to be, in Brasília, people outside of politics", analyzes Corbo.
"There are few names that can be thought of as having the necessary political influence to overcome the trauma that was the rejection of Jorge Messias's name. So the possibility of nomination, be it Rodrigo Pacheco, or some other name that has a lot of appeal with Centrão, tends to still be a possibility", he continues.
Before joining TCU, Pacheco was invited by Lula to run for the government of Minas Gerais with his support, for the PSB, but ended up refusing the proposal.
"For Lula, it could be very positive to have Rodrigo Pacheco in the Supreme Court as a politician who is not from his party, but who has some political alignments with him", assesses Corbo.
Credit, EPA/Shutterstock
Lula defends changes in the choice of ministers
Aware of the new difficulties in approving ministers for the STF, Lula began to defend changes in the process for choosing nominees, but without a closed proposal yet. The new model, which would depend on Congress approving a constitutional change, could be a way of trying to strengthen future nominations before the Senate.
"I think it can't just be the president who nominates [minister for the STF]. We have to create a criterion for how to involve civil society so that we can nominate someone who isn't just at the whim of the President of the Republic or the OAB [Brazilian Bar Association]," said Lula in September.
According to Ingrid Dantas, there are countries that already use advice in the process of choosing nominees, such as South Africa, Canada, Ireland and the United Kingdom. These are collegiate bodies that elect a preliminary list of jurists so that the president can then choose the nominee.
The composition of these councils varies in each country, but they are usually made up of representatives from different institutions, such as leaders from the legal profession, academia or even members of the Three Powers (Executive, Legislative and Judiciary).
Dantas proposes a model for Brazil in his book, published in 2025 based on his doctoral thesis — Constitutional redesigns of the STF: institutional design for a Supreme Court between democratic resistance and judicial politicization.
His suggestion is that a council be created with members from the Public Ministry, the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB), the judiciary, the public defender's office and public law, as well as representatives from civil society and the majority and minority of the Chamber of Deputies.
"It would be a body with a plural composition, responsible for nominating three names. This triple list would go to the President of the Republic, who would choose one to be examined by the Senate", states Dantas.
The proposal, he continues, would have a mechanism to avoid blocking open vacancies. If the first name was rejected, the president would successively nominate another from the list. And, if none were approved, there would be a vote in the Senate between the three chosen by the council.
STF could go almost a decade without renewal
Professor at the State University of Rio de Janeiro (UERJ) and the Central European University (CEU), constitutionalist Juliana Cesario Alvim notes that the next appointments will shape the composition of the STF for an extended period.
While Lula may have multiple nominations until 2030, the next president, whose term will run from 2031 to 2034, only has one nomination scheduled, following the retirement of Edson Fachin, scheduled for February 2033.
After that, the next ministers to retire compulsorily would be Dias Toffoli (November 2042) and Flávio Dino (April 2043) — in other words, the STF could remain without renewal for almost a decade.
"So, not only is it a new formation of the Court [which will be shaped in the coming years], it is a new formation that will stay for a long time, unless something exceptional happens", notes Cesario Alvim.
These forecasts may change if ministers choose to leave the STF before the age of 75, as happened with Barroso, or if there is a death, as happened with Teori Zavascki in 2017. Teori died in a plane crash.
Another factor that could bring forward the resumption of the Court's renewal before 2042 is if Congress approves some type of mandate for ministers. This proposal has been circulating among different political groups, after the serious crisis in the Court, amid the Banco Master scandal.
The impeachment factor
With a majority in the Senate as of February, the Bolsonarist bench has as its important banner the impeachment of STF ministers — 54 votes are needed to approve the impeachment of a member of the Court.
The minister most targeted by Bolsonarism is Alexandre de Moraes, rapporteur of the process that condemned former president Jair Bolsonaro for an attempted coup d'état.
Moraes became more vulnerable after more details were revealed in September about his alleged interactions with banker Daniel Vorcaro and the contract signed by his wife's office, Viviane Barci de Moraes, and Banco Master.
The STF must still analyze whether to open an investigation against Moraes and other ministers mentioned in conversations on Moraes' cell phone, such as Kassio Nunes Marques.
Messages found by the Federal Police on Vorcaro's cell phone point to payments made by Vorcaro to law firms that have cases being processed at the Federal Regional Court of the 1st Region (TRF1), where federal judge Newton Ramos works. Messages also obtained by BBC News Brasil suggest that Newton Ramos is mentioned by Vorcaro's interlocutors along with the term "KN Gang".
Furthermore, according to a report by the newspaper O Globo, a dialogue found on Vorcaro's cell phone mentions a payment of R$500,000 to Kevin Marques, the minister's son, who denied to the newspaper that he had received funds from Banco Master.
Both Alexandre de Moraes and Kassio Nunes Marques deny any illegal involvement with the banker.
Analysts interviewed by the report consider it possible that one or more STF ministers will be impeached, but they do not consider this scenario to be inevitable.
"I think there may be incentives for a composition that does not lead to impeachment, which does not necessarily mean that it would be an ideal scenario, because it could still mean a Court in a corner, which modifies its behavior to avoid the impeachment of ministers", says constitutionalist Ana Laura Barbosa, professor at Insper.
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




