In the last ten years alone, Peru has had nine presidents, six of them with interrupted terms. Specialists explain that this infinite political instability responds to failures of origin, with a legal system that disproportionately empowers Parliament and a crisis of parties without filters or capacity for representation.

First modification: 02/20/2026 - 22:46

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

A position with little oxygen. On Thursday, February 19, Peru saw its ninth ruler sworn in so far in the last decade. José Balcázar, who is originally a congressman, was appointed by Parliament to succeed the dismissed José Jerí, whose interim mandate had begun just four months ago, after the removal of Dina Boluarte. However, and as is customary in the South American country, the political crisis has not ended, since – like his predecessors – Balcázar is raising questions that are shaking his permanence in power.

According to specialists consulted by France 24 en Español, the infinite cycle of presidential volatility in Peru responds to failures in the legal and political system, which have blurred the balance of powers and weakened the quality filters between representatives. For this reason, they warn that the general elections next April only guarantee a renewal of actors, but not greater restraint in the use of constitutional tools or better ethical filters from the parties.

Read alsoAccused of corruption and in favor of child marriage: this is José María Balcázar, new president of Peru

Here, the three keys that explain why in Peru the fall of presidents is so recurrent:

1. Politicians who do not pass the moral test

24 hours after donning the presidential sash, José Balcázar was already cornered with accounts to render. The media recalled questions and revealed complaints about the new occupant of the Government Palace. In addition to his support for child marriage during a public session of Congress, the 83-year-old leftist is also accused of corruption dating back to his time as dean of the Bar Association of the Lambayeque region.

Additionally, he is accused of an alleged exchange of favors to benefit a former attorney general with his vote as a parliamentarian in a sanctioning process. In its edition of Friday, February 20, the local newspaper 'El Comercio' highlighted on its cover that Balcázar – expelled as a judge – was also a lawyer for two individuals convicted of sexual abuse of minors.

It should be remembered that the now former president José Jerí, who will return to his duties as a congressman, was removed by Parliament on February 17 after he accumulated scandals related to secret meetings with a Chinese businessman and irregular hiring and visits of women both in his parliamentary office and in the headquarters of the Executive. Jerí had also been denounced for rape before taking office.

In Peru, with few exceptions, none of the presidents elected by popular vote or those who have been appointed by Congress are immune from criminal charges or unethical behavior. In fact, there are already four former presidents currently serving prison terms; Among them are two who governed in the last decade: Pedro Castillo (2021-2022) and Martín Vizcarra (2018-2020).

Read alsoNine presidents in 10 years, the reflection of political instability in Peru

In an interview with France 24, former Minister of Justice Ana Neyra Zegarra commented that Peruvian political parties have been in crisis for years and that, at the time, Congress refused to approve mechanisms that would improve the electoral offer. Therefore, it is no longer surprising for citizens to see that politicians with complaints rise to power.

"[Improvements in the electoral offer] are complex to ensure, but a mechanism that can serve this objective are the primary elections, which the congressional parties left void when it was proposed. I insist that the filters, more than for a regulatory issue, must also be generated by citizen participation. However, it is complex to sustain expectations of electoral penalties - that is, for citizens to pressure changes in the transparency of the parties in exchange for their vote - because it has to be felt in sufficient volume to discourage their behavior," he explained.

Neyra maintained that the lack of transparency in parties is a normalized practice to the point that it is applied strategically in a very public way, as occurred in the secret ballot election of José Balcázar on February 18:

“No one wanted to visibly assume individual responsibility for bringing someone who was questioned back to the Presidency,” added the also specialist in electoral law.

2. A fragmented but powerful Congress

Although there are no large party majorities in the current Peruvian Parliament, time has revealed coalitions that agree for common objectives without the need to coincide ideologically. Thus, right-wing political groups – such as Fuerza Popular (party of former presidential candidate Keiko Fujimori), Popular Renewal or Alliance for Progress – and left-wing factions, such as Perú Libre (the party that brought Pedro Castillo to the Presidency and of which the current president Balcázar is also a member), have added enough votes in key decisions.

Although it is one of the institutions most rejected by Peruvians and this month has 80% disapproval, Congress in turn brings together greater power over other State entities, including the Executive. This is due to regulatory modifications approved by the Legislature itself, which in practice have reduced the dynamics of counterweights. On the other hand, Parliament has maintained in the Constitution the concept of “permanent moral incapacity” – of broad interpretation – to remove presidents.

"The presidential vacancy (removal) due to permanent moral incapacity, contained in article 113 of the Peruvian Constitution, was never originally intended as a control mechanism, as has been applied in Congress against some presidents in the last decade. It is a mechanism that was foreseen in exceptional cases, when the acting president shows a lack of conscience or mental capacity. That is something that Parliaments have avoided specifying because the open interpretation facilitates indiscriminate use," the subject specialist told this medium. Peruvian electoral and parliamentary Jorge Jáuregui Mendieta.

To declare the vacancy of a president due to moral incapacity, Congress requires the support of two-thirds of its 130-member forum; that is, currently, 87 votes. However, unlike other cases such as that of Martín Vizcarra (removed in 2020), Pedro Castillo (removed in 2022) and Dina Boluarte (removed in 2025), for the removal of José Jerí, Congress applied the figure of censure: he was stripped of the position of president of Parliament and, with this, he also fell as president.

For former minister Ana Neyra, this new precedent in the Jerí case makes the presidential position even more vulnerable when it is occupied by congressmen. As recalled, when in Peru there are no vice presidents left in the Executive and the acting president is removed or resigns, the person who assumes office by constitutional mandate is the head of Parliament. The latter has already happened on four occasions, with Manuel Merino, Francisco Sagasti, José Jerí and José Balcázar; all originally presidents of Congress.

"I think that, since the absence of the president and vice presidents has been repeated so much, and having had to resort to replacing them with the president of Congress, a reinterpretation of how to remove rulers is being forced. With Jerí, this idea has been reached that the modality is censure. And that, even, puts the position at greater risk because the majority required to censure the president of Congress is quite low [a simple majority is required and in the case of Jerí 75 votes were enough]," comments Neyra.

Read alsoWas the motion of censure against interim president José Jerí in Peru appropriate?

3. The normalization of the power imbalance

With a Congress that can invoke the cause of permanent moral incapacity to remove leaders and an Executive that can lose authority by dint of votes in the chamber, the Peruvian presidential system has mutated – according to experts – into forced parliamentarism or even parliamentary authoritarianism.

In 2023, the Peruvian Parliament approved modifications to the trust issue mechanism, which limited the use that the Executive can give it to pressure Congress. For example, the scenario of 2019 could not be repeated, when then-president Martín Vizcarra and his cabinet imposed a question of confidence in the parliamentary election of new members of the Constitutional Court, which resulted in Vizcarra dissolving Parliament.

"On the one hand, Congress has reviewed the prerogatives of the Executive, which in practice has eliminated the possibility of the Executive dissolving Congress. On the other hand, the power that Congress has over the Executive has not been reviewed. And this is very clear because the vacancy due to moral incapacity has not been modified. Part of the problem has to do with the fact that norms have been revised with respect to a single power and not under the idea of creating adequate counterweights. That is why there is talk now that we have a kind of legislative authoritarianism, which has a lot of power and little control,” says former minister Ana Neyra.

The constitutionalist Gabriela Oporto Patroni agreed that the weakening of the presidential figure will continue if there are no urgent regulatory modifications or restorations.

"There have been changes that affected the Executive's ability to force the hand of Congress and, in politics, practices force the normalization of how to do things. It is urgent to specify in the Constitution that permanent moral incapacity does not refer to ethical incapacity, but intellectual, to modernize the terms a little. The changes to the question of trust introduced two Congresses ago must also be undone. This could return to a slightly more balanced dynamic," explained Oporto.

Specialist Jorge Jáuregui added that the Peruvian model – originally presidential – “is overloaded with typical institutes of parliamentarism, such as the vote of confidence or the censure of ministers and cabinets, and worse still, with the presidential vacancy due to permanent moral incapacity, which is already misinterpreted.”

Read alsoIn Peru, economic stability contrasts with political instability

4. A near future without good projections

On April 12, Peruvians will go to the polls to elect a new president in an unusual process, where 34 candidates are presented. In addition to the president, a new national Congress will be elected – this time, bicameral, which reintroduces the Senate – and also members of the Andean Parliament. For the experts consulted by France 24 en Español, the expansion of the number of congressmen in Peru, which will go from 130 to 190 due to the addition of 60 senators, does not guarantee qualitative or reflective improvements in the use of power.

"I have a realistic projection of what is coming. It is an election with a huge offer, so it is likely that the vote will be quite fragmented in general. It has been projected that, more or less, only five or six political forces will pass the electoral fence and gain space in the chamber of deputies and senators. We are talking about more than 30 parties that are presenting themselves and only five or six - most likely the most well-known - that will achieve representation. I do not believe, then, that the new Congress will to be substantially different from this. It seems too idealistic to me,” says Ana Neyra.

“There is no empirical evidence to demonstrate that a bicameral system works better than a unicameral one” and that “the way the political system in Peru is designed right now, having two chambers intensifies the problems we already have of underrepresentation in Parliament,” says Jorge Jáuregui.

In turn, constitutionalist Gabriela Oporto expressed that a fragmented Congress like the one projected will potentially repeat tensions with the Executive and that the electoral offer, with political parties without incentives to filter their candidates, would also lead to a level similar to the current one, where private or partisan interests prevail and not the public interest.

Read alsoFrom Kuczynski to Jerí: the cost of a new scandal in Peru

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.