The victory of progressive Abdul El-Sayed in the mid-term elections, after a campaign marked by his criticism of Israel, illustrates the erosion of American public support for the Jewish state since the wars in Gaza and Iran. Between the cost of living linked to tensions in the Middle East and isolationist aspirations on the right, the historic alignment of the United States with the Israeli government is also wavering.

Published on: 05/11/2026 - 17:27 Modified on: 05/11/2026 - 17:37

By winning the election in Michigan during the 2026 midterms, Abdul El-Sayed became, on Tuesday, November 3, the first elected American senator of Muslim faith, after a campaign during which attacks on his religion were numerous. Coming from the left wing of the Democratic Party, this 42-year-old doctor, son of Egyptian immigrants, campaigned above all on the cost of living and access to public services. Yet it was his faith and his opposition to Israeli policy in Gaza that put him in the spotlight.

His victory demonstrates that support for Israel is no longer a sine qua non condition for being elected, whatever the side of the American political spectrum. And that beyond the ideological issue, it is the direct economic impact of the conflicts in the Middle East on the daily lives of Americans which contributed to the blue wave of the mid-term elections. A result which now shakes this diplomatic dogma which prevailed on the Democratic and Republican sides.

“The overwhelming victory of the Democrats and the crushing defeat of the Republicans sums up the next chapter in relations between the United States and Israel,” Udi Sommer, professor of political science at Tel Aviv University, told Reuters.

Read alsoMidterms: the Republican rout weakens the future of Pete Hegseth at the Pentagon

“We want our taxes to be spent here, for our schools, our health system and our infrastructure. We do not want our money to be used to finance apartheid, genocide or war,” said in his victory speech the man who was notably accused by the Republicans – without proof – of belonging to the Muslim Brotherhood. "They're trying to label you as hateful if you think Palestinian children should be able to grow up in the land of their ancestors without being killed with our tax money. If you believe in equal rights, peace, dignity and self-determination, that's not hate. It's love."

To display this YouTube content, it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.

An extension in your browser appears to be blocking the loading of the video player. To be able to watch this content, you must disable or uninstall it.

Media defeats for AIPAC

The now senator also allowed himself a dig at AIPAC, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, the pro-Israeli lobby in the United States. The latter first supported the candidacy of El-Sayed's competitor in the primary, Haley Stevens, then that of his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers, exceeding a total of $42 million in expenses: "Thank you for giving me the opportunity to fight you twice."

This is not the only defeat for AIPAC and supporters of support for Israel. Next January, the House of Representatives will include, among its new members, figures from this protest. Like military doctor Adam Hamawy or elected official Brad Lander, firmly opposed to the pursuit of unconditional military aid, who are, in particular, in the tradition of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or Ilhan Omar.

Read alsoMidterms 2026: these victories and these faces which are shaking up the American political landscape

Despite these high-profile defeats, AIPAC welcomed the victories of "234 of its candidates" over X, including that of Hakeem Jeffries, likely future Speaker of the House of Representatives, and Chuck Schumer, tipped to lead the majority in the Senate. According to the electoral financing monitoring site “Who Funds My Rep”, AIPAC actually records a success rate of 91% in elections. A fact to be qualified however, the organization supporting many outgoing elected officials and favorites.

War led to inflation

The first surveys coming out of the polls note that voters did not transform the vote into a referendum against the war in Gaza. On the other hand, they wanted to sanction the war launched on February 28 against Iran, alongside Israel, and American interventionism in the Middle East.

And it is not the morality of the war – or not – that is targeted, but its consequences: with the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, prices have soared in the United States, particularly those of fuel.

“We really want someone who ends the war, and the price of gasoline goes down,” said Gharam, a 19-year-old barista from Michigan, met just before the election. “This is who we are going to vote for: anyone who promises us an end to the war, low prices at the pump. A better life.”

To display this Instagram content, it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.

JD Vance makes support for Israel a reason for defeat

If the rise of the progressive wave is undeniable within the blue tsunami of the midterms, the tide could be turning to the Republican side. In the middle of election day, Donald Trump announced his desire to end annual security aid of $3.8 billion to Israel, assuring that he “no longer needs it.” If the American president assured that the decision had been taken in agreement with the Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, this choice was widely criticized from all sides. Supporters of Israel saw it as an “unserious” announcement, while opponents criticized an opportunistic and electoral change of course.

Read alsoAfter the rout of the midterms, the settling of scores begins among the Republicans

However, the American president is not the only one to initiate a change of attitude. When listing the four priorities that should motivate Republicans after his camp's defeat, JD Vance specifically mentions the link with Israel: "End the war in Iran, focus on the cost of living, put America first and change our relationship with Israel." In his sights, a real return to “America First”.

“The old bipartisan consensus on Israel no longer exists,” judges Beth Miller in the Guardian. And with the end of this consensus, the political director of Jewish Voice for Peace Action believes that the next Congress could pass a number of measures, ranging from an arms embargo on Israel to sanctions against violent settlers and political leaders. Only the presidential veto could block them.

“We are still talking about local elections, but they reveal a worrying development in the American political landscape. The sanction against Donald Trump is real, as is the generational change within political leadership. This transformation risks, in the long term, further distancing the United States from Israel,” says Myriam Shermer, a journalist specializing in the Israeli political system on i24NEWS. "These elections constitute a worrying signal in the long term, without necessarily announcing an immediate disengagement of the United States. Everything will depend on Donald Trump's arbitration between internal political pressures and his ambition to remain in History as the one who transformed the Middle East."

In Israel too, the lines are moving

This erosion of bipartisan consensus in Washington directly weakens the strategy of Benjamin Netanyahu, whose influence was largely based on the flawless alignment of the two major American parties. In Israel, the concern is real. Coming out of its own electoral sequence, the governing coalition lost its majority in the Knesset. However, the Israeli Prime Minister has not said his last word, negotiations are also underway in the opposition to try to form a majority.

Also read: Israel: Eisenkot well placed to form the next government with the support of Arab parties

In this context, Yaïr Golan, leader of the center-left Democrats (former Labor Party), estimated, in a message on the X platform, that the results of the elections in the United States "reveal the extent to which Netanyahu is unpopular among both Democrats and Republicans."

To display this X content (Twitter), it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.

The Republican setback shows that Israel "cannot afford" for Benjamin Netanyahu to remain in power, added the leader of the centrist opposition, Yaïr Lapid. “It endangers our security, it compromises our democracy and it will ruin our image on the international scene,” he wrote in a message published on social networks.

Unlike previous Israeli leaders, who took care of their relations with both Democrats and Republicans, Benjamin Netanyahu showcased his proximity to Donald Trump, who in return gave him his support for the elections at the end of October. Without apparent success for the two men.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.