Credit, AFP via Getty Images

Shortly after the results of the elections on October 25, a 13-year-old black student, a scholarship student at a private school in Belo Horizonte, published on her closed Instagram account an opinion favorable to the victory of Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT).

In response, the student began to receive a series of text and audio messages with serious insults, with content perceived by the young woman's family as racist, religious intolerance, class prejudice and threats of a sexual nature, including insults against the girl's mother, father and grandmother.

"Daughter of Exu, Candomblé elite, Zé Pilintra is her father", said one of the attackers, according to audios to which BBC News Brasil had access.

"You poor bastard, my house is worth R$10 million, it's worth more than your entire soul," said another.

Many of the audios contain language that is too offensive to be reproduced in this report, including those that directly quote Lula. The family also reports that one of the boys sent a photo of his buttocks to the student.

According to the family, the messages were sent through the Instagram account of one of the girl's classmates, as well as two other teenagers who do not study at the same school. The messages were later deleted, but recorded before that by the girl's mother.

"I was outraged, I couldn't believe I was seeing so much from a child – because, for me, they are still children", says the student's mother, whose identity will be preserved.

"I was very impacted by their statements, by the verbal attacks against women, because there was another classmate with whom they also did this," she says.

End of Most read

Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service

Download here

End of app promotion

The mother says that, in addition to recording the offenses, she responded immediately to the attackers through her daughter's Instagram account.

"I said that what they were doing to her would result in punishment, that I was supposed to respect her and respect me too, because they didn't know me to talk about my social class, our house, the neighborhood where we live. I asked for respect", he says.

The mother filed a police report about the case with the Minas Gerais Civil Police on Tuesday (10/27). The bulletin qualifies what happened as insult by electronic means, with a presumed cause of racism.

The Civil Police of Minas Gerais states that the facts are already being investigated by the State Department of Investigation, Guidance and Family Protection (Defam) and that "other information may be released at an appropriate time".

According to the family, the student had already suffered other episodes of verbal aggression at school, which had dealt with the cases in a "passive and formal" way. The mother says, however, that she did not go to the police in previous episodes for fear of her daughter losing her scholarship.

"This time, I decided that I wouldn't keep silent like I had other times out of fear," he says.

"And I hope it is taken seriously, that there is punishment for boys and parents, so they can teach their children to have respect for others, regardless of social status, color, religion, political party. This is no joke."

Lawyer Victor Alves, who represents the family, highlights the importance of cases like these being brought to justice.

"It is important not only from a legal point of view, but also from a pedagogical, institutional, social and comprehensive protection point of view for children and adolescents", says Alves.

"We need to break with the naturalization of racism, protect the dignity and emotional health of the girl, produce accountability (even when those involved are minors), prevent the repetition of violence and produce institutional change."

This Tuesday (11/3), the family and lawyer had a meeting with the school.

According to Alves, at the meeting, the educational institution offered to provide all institutional and legal support to the victim, offering the necessary conditions to ensure the physical, mental and moral integrity of the child.

Questioned by BBC News Brasil, the school (whose name will also be preserved to protect the minors involved) stated that "it does not condone any form of racism, discrimination, religious intolerance, violence or embarrassment, reaffirming its commitment to a safe, inclusive and respectful educational environment".

The institution reported that it is verifying the information received and adopting the relevant internal procedures. The school also stated that it was unable to comment on the details of the specific case to protect the data of minors and that, after checking the facts, it could comment again.

The Belo Horizonte episode is not an isolated case.

Last week, the newspaper Folha de S.Paulo recorded cases of political violence against students after elections in schools in the Federal District, Paraná and São Paulo.

The newspaper O Globo highlighted a case involving a private school in Barra da Tijuca, in Rio de Janeiro, and the Su21 portal, a series of cases involving educational institutions in Rio Grande do Sul.

BBC News Brasil also reported in reports the boycott lists against "PT businesses" and cases of doctors accused of persecuting colleagues and suggesting a boycott of patients due to their political stance in the elections.

The Public Ministry of Labor (MPT) reported on Saturday (10/31) that it received more than 4,300 reports of electoral harassment at work between October 28 and 30 alone, the first three days of operation of a channel created to receive these reports, which began operating after the second round.

Persecution against teachers

In addition to violence against students, school employees and teachers have also reported cases of political persecution. The Minas Gerais State Teachers' Union (Sinpro Minas), which represents teachers in the state's private sector, publicly denounced cases of harassment.

According to Valéria Morato, president of Sinpro Minas, by Friday (10/30), the union had already received 15 complaints of this type.

"These are allegations of intimidation by colleagues and school management. They say that whoever voted for 13 should lose their job, that they shouldn't even be greeted — this by colleagues, in the teachers' room", he reports.

"There was a case of management saying that, if the school loses students, the first to be fired will certainly be those who voted for 13. And we also have reports of students organizing to film classes to 'catch some loophole' and then publish it on the internet."

Credit, Getty Images

According to the union leader, these are cases of harassment, which is a crime, in addition to constituting the practice of psychological violence against teachers. Sinpro Minas participated in a meeting on Thursday (10/29) with representatives from the Labor Court, MPT, Federal Police, Attorney General's Office and trade union centrals.

"Punishing teachers for their democratic engagement is using administrative power against democracy, replacing public debate with collective embarrassment," the union said in a statement after the meeting. "This logic cannot be naturalized in schools in Minas Gerais."

Morato recommends that teachers who are victims of political harassment contact their unions so as not to expose themselves when making a complaint, and it is up to the unions to take action in these cases.

Workers who suffer or witness situations of electoral harassment or politically motivated discrimination in the workplace can also file complaints directly through the following channels, confidentially:

What to do in case of political violence against students

Professor Luciene Regina Tognetta, from the Department of Educational Psychology at Unesp (Universidade Estadual Paulista) and leader of the Study and Research Group on Moral Education (Gepem), highlights first that it is necessary to call what is happening by the correct name.

According to her, the attacks against students after the elections are cases of political violence, and not “political bullying”. This is because bullying is continuous and repeated violence against people in fragile situations, he explains, while recent episodes in the post-election period are more episodic in nature.

"As a result, the type of intervention changes, bullying requires procedural intervention and these cases require specific intervention [from the school]", he states.

Credit, Reuters

Tognetta states that political violence reaches schools because the same relationships as in society in general are reproduced there.

“Disrespectful relationships will happen in the same way as in society,” he says. "The difference, at school, is what will be done with it."

In cases like that of the Belo Horizonte student, in which there is clear evidence of racial insult, religious intolerance, among other possible crimes, the specialist recommends that parents document the attacks and file a police report.

"In these cases, there is no debate as to whether this is right or wrong, because racism, xenophobia, religious intolerance are prohibited by law," he states.

"What does the father need to do? Ensure that the law is followed and that his son has his rights respected, so he needs to file a police report and go to a police station."

Regarding school, the teacher argues that cases of aggression must be treated in a pedagogical way, understanding the school as a training space, whether for the aggressors or the victims. In this sense, she argues that expulsion of aggressors is not the best path, and that the school must promote dialogue between the parties, seeking to restore coexistence.

"Expulsion won't solve it, it will take these students to another school where they will do the same thing", he states. "The victim needs to be able to be heard and the aggressor needs to make amends for what he did. If not, I will never graduate for life in society."

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

Is it a crime to make lists of 'PT' businesses to promote a boycott?

Doctors are accused of persecuting colleagues and suggesting a boycott of patients for political reasons: 'I felt a target on my head'

The epidemic of violence against teachers in Brazil: 'I was threatened with death by the father of a 6-year-old student'

Top news

5 reasons for Trump's party's disaster in the US elections

Who is Abdul El-Sayed, the first Muslim elected senator in the USA

Talarico, the religious Democrat who spoke of a 'non-binary' God and swept conservative Texas

read more

Most clicked