Photo credit: AFP via Getty Images

Hungary has published a complete archive of state security documents on the Internet. It reveals who spied on neighbors, colleagues, friends and relatives during the four decades of communist rule that lasted until 1989.

For some, the release of the archives is a long-awaited opportunity to finally learn the details of the disappearances, arrests and interrogations carried out by the communist state and its vast network of spies.

For others, it's the possibility that painful secrets buried for decades will come to light.

The government says this is a critical step in Hungary's democratic transition process. Critics argue that the government was late in releasing it, that the dossiers themselves are incomplete, and that their release could divide society and cause unnecessary suffering to family members.

“I ask everyone to treat this long-overdue publication of documents with dignity and humanity,” Prime Minister Peter Magyar told reporters at the state archives in Budapest. “Many families are now faced with difficult information, often relating to a deceased relative.”

The promise to open the archives was central to Magyar's campaign for the April elections that ended Viktor Orban's rule. Previous governments have considered releasing the dossier but ultimately decided against it.

Previously, Hungarians could submit requests to check the archives to find out whether they were under surveillance or whether someone in their family was an informant. Since 1998, it has become possible to apply for access to one's own file, and for historians to examine the files of others. However, many names were hidden, as was access to a large number of dossiers, which were retained for their use by the new Hungarian intelligence services that replaced the communist ones.

Over the past 36 years, there have been frequent leaks of data from these dossiers: successive governments have not shied away from using them in the election campaign. Many files were also destroyed after the fall of the communist regime.

End of Most Popular

Photo by nyitottaktak.hu

This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.

Download extension

End of story Chrome browser extension - link

A typical entry contains the informant's real name, code name, date of birth, address and mother's name, motive for recruitment - whether he cooperated voluntarily or under duress - and the name of his handler.

Another batch of documents, known as "Dossier B", is currently being digitized and will be available on February 25 next year.

These documents provide much more detailed information about the recruitment process, as well as the value of the information they provide.

Critics of opening the dossier emphasize this point: they believe that people will be too quick to judge those whose names end up in the dossier and will not want to delve into the nuances.

It is estimated that between December 1944 and February 1990, between 150,000 and 180,000 citizens were recruited as informants in Hungary, a country of just over 10 million people. Of the informants named in the files released Wednesday, between 5,000 and 8,000 are believed to be still alive.

Many were blackmailed with threats such as losing their jobs or educational opportunities, losing access to medications, or divulging information about their intimate lives or addictions. Such intimate details have been carefully removed from the materials already released.

The vast majority of evidence of this mass surveillance program was destroyed during the 1956 uprising and the fall of communism in 1989.

The archives contain the names of 50,000 - 60,000 informants, said the head of the Historical Archives of the State Security of Hungary, Gergego Bendeguz Csech.

“We are digitizing and publishing all the files of former agents,” says Cech. “This way it will become obvious, at least based on the documents that have survived, not only that someone was recruited, but also on what grounds, how the recruitment took place, how they were blackmailed and how they acted.”

While the documents released Wednesday contain tens of thousands of names, historians caution that just because a name is on the list does not necessarily mean the person actually reported his fellow citizens to government security agencies. In many cases, only parts of the data survive, without any description of whether people were recruited or what activities they carried out.

image copyrightGetty Images

The released documents do not include the name of former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban. However, in connection with the publication of the dossier, allegations have also emerged that Orban denounced his fellow soldiers during his compulsory military service in 1981.

These accusations, in particular, are contained in a new book by Szabolcs Panyi, one of the country's leading investigative journalists.

Pagnyi draws on the testimony of Miklós Németh, Hungary's last communist prime minister, who oversaw the transition to liberal democracy from 1988–1990. According to the book, in 1990 Németh was presented with three handwritten reports that Orbán allegedly passed on to his handlers in the communist intelligence services.

Meanwhile, Orbán himself has described his military service, during which he was disciplined several times for insubordination, as the turning point that made him a committed anti-regime fighter in the late 1980s.

Orban, who served as prime minister from 1998 until April this year, responded to the allegations by publishing several documents on social media that are said to show he rejected attempts to recruit him as an informant and was subsequently placed under surveillance.

As an opposition activist in communist Hungary in the 1980s, Balint Magyar knew he was under close surveillance.

Since then, he has been able to obtain pieces of information that the state had secretly collected about his life, including a police informant's report of a speech he gave to a group of teachers in 1987 in which he "declared that regime change would soon occur in our country."

Now Magyar treats this with humor. "I didn't remember that even then, so early, I was talking about the possibility of regime change," he tells BBC World Service.

He still doesn't know who the informant was—or any details about the surveillance operation—but he might find out soon.

“The system itself and how it operates have never been made public,” he says. “Perhaps having full access to all documents will now give everyone a clearer picture of the system as a whole.”

Peter "Siami" Müller was part of the underground rock scene in Hungary in the 1980s. Police informants were always on duty in the crowd.

“You were reported on, taken to the police station - this happened all the time,” he says.

Mueller spent years fighting the communist regime but is reluctant to identify collaborators.

“I don’t really like the idea that society still needs this kind of ‘cleansing’ or ‘catharsis’ – that people need to be singled out, humiliated, shamed and punished when they’re either dead or have moved on to another stage of life,” he says.

Photo copyright: Reuters

Legislation on the release of archives was passed in September. After his landslide victory over Viktor Orbán in April's elections, Prime Minister Peter Magyar said his government would "deliver one of the most important promises of the democratic transition - we will open up existing archives and make them searchable." The release of the archives, he said, will help pay off “a 36-year debt to those who were spied on, who were blackmailed and whose lives were destroyed.”

End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletter

However, according to Balint Magyar, the publication of these materials occurred too late for prosecution.

“The question is no longer who should be held accountable or who else can be held accountable, since most of that generation have already died and the rest have passed the age of active working life,” he says.

Having become a member of parliament and a government minister after the fall of communism, Balint Magyar now works as a senior researcher at the Institute of Democracy at the Central European University in Budapest.

And for him, the significance of releasing archives goes beyond holding individuals accountable.

“A nation cannot continue to live a lie without somehow confronting its past,” he says. “Opening the archives will certainly help Hungary do this.”

Hungary has much more to learn about this dark past.

Supporters of the initiative say it is a big step towards historic reconciliation. But for some it will be quite painful.

Download the new BBC World Service app!

When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.

Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

Find out more

Video playlist

End Video playlist

They want to transfer the Stasi documents to the federal archives. Why are many researchers against it?

How a schoolboy from the GDR was imprisoned for a letter he wrote to the BBC

Dungeons and archives: a BBC correspondent visited abandoned facilities of the Syrian intelligence services

Main

New NABU investigation into call centers, drugs and counterfeit euros: SBU general detained

Spies, informants and secret police: Hungary opens the archives of its communist past

LIVE Live, War in Ukraine: authorities report massive attack on Ryazan; the number of victims in Kamyshevakha increased to 42

Don't miss it

Popular