Torture, smoke suffocation, deportation, and forced disappearance... Historical events prompt the question: Can we compare the massacres committed by France in its former colonies, with those carried out by the Nazis on June 10, 1944 in the French town of Oradour-sur-Glane? For political science professor Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison, who devoted his latest book to this issue, which in 2025 was the subject of media and political controversy, historians have long since decided their position.

Published on: 04/20/2026 - 19:21

The statements of French journalist Jean-Michel Abate on RTL radio on February 25, 2025, sparked widespread controversy in France that reached an unprecedented extent. Abate asked at the time: “Every year in France we commemorate what happened in Oradour-sur-Glane, meaning the massacre of an entire village. But we committed hundreds of others like it in Algeria. Are we aware of that?”

He was even accused at the time of "not liking France." Jordan Bardella, head of the far-right National Rally party, accused him of "abhorrently falsifying history." As for Eric Ciotti (Union for the Republic), he accused him of “nationalist propaganda.” Cyril Hanouna, who presents a program on one of the Vincent Bolloré group's channels, was also surprised by "comparing France to Nazi Germany." In the face of this fierce political and media campaign, and then his suspension from work by the RTL administration, Jean-Michel Abate decided to leave his work at the radio, even though he had the support of many historians.

But Olivier Le-Cour Grandmaison, professor of political science and political philosophy at the University of Paris-Saclay, believes that this “scandal” reveals “the triumph of the biases of the republican national myth over historical truth.” The thinker posed a fundamental question: Did France commit massacres against civilians that could be compared to this incident, which constitutes a symbol of Nazi brutality during its colonial invasion in the 19th and 20th centuries?

In fact, this is exactly what Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison tried to answer through his book “Oradour - The French Colonists against the “National Narrative”” published in 2025 by Les Lien qui Liber.

In this edition, the political expert explains how the national narrative, “the glorious narrative of the reputation of French history,” allowed the “extreme brutality of French colonialism” to be hidden and denied.

France 24: “Oradour - The French Colonists”.. Why this title? To shock?

Olivier Le-Cour Grandmaison: That is not the aim of the book. Rather, it is a matter of returning to historical facts that have been established for a very long time. Oradour was mentioned very early in the aftermath of World War II, notably through the intervention of an Algerian Communist Party deputy during the Constituent National Assembly in December 1945 (Algeria was then still a French province, and was sending deputies to Parliament in Paris - editor's note).

On May 8, 1945, horrific massacres occurred in Algeria, resulting in the deaths of between 30,000 and 35,000 people. The French army and colonial militias committed massacres of civilians, in some cases even burning bodies in lime kilns to dispose of them. The methods of intimidation and massacres leave no doubt that they resemble those used by the Das Reich band in Oradour-sur-Glane.

Read also French parliamentarians from the left commemorate the “massacres” of May 8, 1945 in Algeria

On the other hand, during the period of General Bougou's invasion of Algeria, well-documented and well-known events occurred. Thomas Robert Pigot issued the following order to his officers who were preparing to participate in that campaign: “If these scoundrels (the indigenous people - editor’s note) retreat to their caves, eliminate them like foxes.” This order was also carried out by General Pélissier, who committed a "smoke strangulation" that led to the genocide of an entire tribe of one thousand people, including men, women, children and unarmed elders. Here too, we can consider that it is really about massacres similar to those that took place in Orador.

After the outbreak of the Algerian War on November 1, 1954, some resistance fighters spoke of the "Gestapo of Algeria." For them, the torture methods used by the French army were comparable to those of the Gestapo (German secret police - editor's note). They used the term "French Gestapo" to describe these torture practices, and of course to denounce them.

Reconsidering its colonial history... a purely French phenomenon?

The debate is not between two opposing interpretations of history. Rather, it confronts those who are committed to establishing knowledge and truth with those who defend what falls within the national narrative. This imperial republican myth glosses over, even denies, the crimes committed. It is about a will to falsify and maintain the national myth.

Read also: Algerian Liberation Revolution: Macron admits that Larbi Ben M’hidi “was killed by French soldiers”

France has a somewhat special situation. Compared to the United Kingdom, Germany, Canada and the United States, all of these countries, in one way or another, acknowledged crimes committed during the colonial era or against indigenous people [the British government expressed “sincere regret” for the suppression of the Mau-Mau uprising in Kenya during the 1950s, Germany apologized in 2021 for the “genocide” of the Hereros and Nama tribes in Namibia, etc. - editor’s note]. In some cases, courts have awarded financial compensation to victims or their descendants. The comparison allows to reveal the extent of France's exceptional "backwardness", linked to the constant cowardice of its political authorities, both right and left.

Were these methods used in all French colonies or only in Algeria?

In general, there is a great similarity between the methods of intimidating warfare used against the indigenous peoples in the various lands of the empire. Indochina (Vietnam) and the Algerian War represent a special case: here, the doctrine of counter-revolutionary war was applied. Theories of torture and forced disappearance, which today are classified as crimes against humanity, have been embodied in reality. The French armed forces, with the authorization of political authority, deported two and a half million Algerian civilians and placed them in reconsolidation camps to empty entire regions of their population. The goal was to deprive the FLN (National Liberation Front founded in October 1954 to fight colonialism - editor's note) of any military or logistical support. Mass intimidation tactics were also used after the Algerian War, especially in Cameroon.

French criminal law defines crimes against humanity. Torture and enforced disappearance are considered crimes against humanity when the motives are ethnic, racial, or political. The military acted according to a well-coordinated plan, drawn up by the army, wanted and supported by the politicians. These methods were part of their mission to "calm the situation" in Algeria.

Is the fact that the term “pacification” is not widely taught in France a deliberate attempt to hide colonial conquest?

"Pacification" was the official term used by the political and military authorities during the invasion of Algeria, after General Bogo was appointed Governor-General. He is led to believe that the goal of colonialism was to bring peace to the peoples who were to be conquered and subjugated, and from there to create conditions for the development of those colonies. The events, their chronology, and the responsibilities of the military and politicians have been meticulously documented in many important works. The problem lies in secondary education curricula, which pay little attention to the invasion of Algeria, and France's colonial history in general.

However, there has been significant progress in terms of the content of textbooks. Here I especially remember the issue of slavery and the Black Act of 1685. The problem, however, is that teachers at the secondary level are restricted in working hours and limited. Today, middle and high school students know little, or very little, of France's colonial history.

In 2017, Macron spoke of “crimes against humanity” during his visit to Algeria. After his election, these terms disappeared from his speeches. Did he comply with the national narrative?

He made this statement as a candidate, not as president. Upon his return to Paris, he partially retracted his statements. His taking an explicit position on this issue would have created problems for him in the context of the presidential elections. This also explains why, as head of state, he did nothing to move the needle on the issue of recognition of the colonial crimes committed during the colonization of Algeria.

Read also: The French President honors the victims of the October 17, 1961 demonstrations and considers them “unforgivable incidents for the Republic.”

Macron's position has also constantly changed on these issues. Since the law of February 23, 2005, the National Rally (National Front) and far-right movements have spared no effort to defend France's imperial past: François Fillon, Bruno Rotayo, and Edouard Philippe.

The law of February 23, 2005 on the “positive role of colonialism”... Does it represent a turning point?

It is a major turning point. At that moment, for reasons related to electoral competition, the right-wing majority, that is, the Union for a Popular Movement party led by Nicolas Sarkozy, decided to defend positions that restored France's colonial past, which had originally been the positions of the National Front long ago.

It is a double exception. On the one hand, because France is the only former colonial power to have voted on such a law. On the other hand, because the state has no right to interfere in the humanities, especially history. It should be remembered that this is a matter of establishing an official and defensive interpretation of France's colonial past. It is a completely illiberal position and it harms the necessary independence of the humanities in general, and history in particular.

As a historian, do you think France should come to terms with its past? Algerians demand that she “apologise”

We cannot reconcile with the past, but perhaps with countries that were colonized, specifically Algeria. This passes, of course, through recognition of crimes committed during colonialism. At the very least, these crimes should be considered state crimes and crimes against humanity.

Read also: Frantz Fanon...anti-colonial

Algeria's demands are based on internal and diplomatic considerations at the same time, but they do not necessarily reflect an interest in reaching a historical truth. It is about using history as a political and diplomatic tool. In France, those who work for the recognition of crimes do not use such a moral and religious lexicon. For them, it is a political and legal issue.

The original text is in French, translated into Arabic by: Tariq Balqin

Keywords related to the article

The content you want to browse is no longer in service or is currently unavailable.