Photo copyright: Reuters
Democrats won a landslide victory in the US midterm elections and gained control of both houses of the US Parliament. Why did the Republicans lose so many seats in Congress and how will this affect Trump?
The host of the BBC Russian Service podcast “What Was It”, Seva Boyko, discussed these and other issues with Alexandra Filippenko, a journalist, Americanist, and author of the Elections 2026 telegram channel.
BBC: Alexandra, please tell us who ensured the success of the Democrats and where?
Alexandra Filippenko: Of course, as always, the economy is number one. The economy is the most important issue that interests and worries Americans. He was in first place in surveys of all sociological centers, including the Pew Research Center - this is one of the main sociological centers in the United States. There the Americans very clearly answered the question “what is important to you when voting for this or that candidate?” Yes, the economy comes first, number one, always and as always.
Next is the future of democracy. Now this is very interesting. What is the future of democracy? This means that these are issues related, potentially, including to corruption, potentially related to some kind of transactions. Next are healthcare, education and immigration. And according to the first two points, we can definitely say that this is a vote against Donald Trump.
First of all, we are now witnessing the loss of the Republican Party by Trump. Is this a victory for the Democrats? Is this a victory that can truly ensure the Democrats both the year 2028 and some kind of strengthening of their party in the eyes of the Americans? We have yet to see this, and we will see it in 2027. At this point, we can state that this is, of course, the defeat of MAGA-Trumpism in the form in which it now exists. And, of course, it was the Republicans who ensured the victory for the Democrats. And the choice that Donald Trump made - if you look at the Republican Party primaries, he very often supported not classic Republicans, but MAGA Trumpists - and this largely ensured the victory of the Democrats.
Of course, I would like to join everyone who rejoices at the victory of the Democratic Party. But let's remember the survey that was conducted on the eve of the elections on the attitude of Americans towards different parties. Only 29% of Americans have a positive view of the Democratic Party, while 38% have a positive view of the Republican Party. This tells us that the current election is, of course, as they say, a “referendum on Trump.” And, as always, the presidential party is losing especially in the second midterm elections.
How "Republican" states voted for Democrats
BBC: Let's talk a little about geography and personalities. These midterm congressional elections have seen events that few would have expected just a couple of years ago. Texas, Kansas, Georgia are states where there were no Democratic representatives for a long time, but now they will. What geographical names should our viewers pay attention to? And, accordingly, who is the face of this Democratic victory? With all the reservations you made above.
End of Most Popular
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
A.F.: Of course, the two most interesting points for me are Texas and Michigan - Republican states. Texas is a Republican state that has not elected a Democrat senator since 1988. The 38-year hiatus of Republican Party supremacy was ended by James Talarico, the Democratic candidate. He defeated Ken Paxton. And this is just one example when Donald Trump supported a candidate not a classic Republican, but a MAGA Trumpist, although many Republicans opposed this during the primaries, and lost. Texas is a Republican state, a southern state, the Lone Star State, which is also associated with the Republican Party. But now this is the state that voted for James Talarico.
Did Texas native Matthew McConaughey perhaps play a role in this? Matthew McConaughey called for voting regardless of any historical, party ideas. And even if your parents, even if you voted for the Republican Party for years, they say, vote as an independent voter, be sure to vote. Well, this, of course, is a separate conversation, maybe the role of show business here is not very serious, let’s say, but it’s still worth paying attention to this too.
And Michigan, of course. Abdul El-Sayed, a left-wing Democrat, whom Donald Trump calls a socialist and generally a danger to the American state and generally a supporter of the terrorist organization “Muslim Brotherhood” and so on. Of course, Abdul El-Sayed denies all this, but this left wing of the Democratic Party also won an important victory. I would draw attention to these two points as very serious.
But there is still a lot of interesting things. Kansas is just amazing in itself. What do we associate Kansas with? Of course, The Wizard of Oz. Certainly. This is Kansas, that's what it is! Here's something incredible: Kansas hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932. But here you go, such a deeply Republican state votes for a Democrat. Of course, a very special candidate there is Pastor Adam Hamilton. And he was a Republican before that, it is known that he voted for the Republican Party, he himself presented himself as a Republican. That is, he is a very conservative democrat. But nevertheless, this is still an absolutely stunning result for the Democratic Party.
image copyrightEPA
BBC: I was reading the New York Times newsletter this morning and they pointed out that many minorities will now become senior officials or MPs for the first time. Can you talk a little about that too?
AF: We have yet to see the final results, but the shift of Latino voters back to the Democrats is amazing. Latino voters supported the Republican Party, supported Donald Trump. But here is the first woman, Latino governor in Texas, the first Latino governor in California. First female Native American governor in New Mexico. These are very, very important indicators. Well, in general, of course, we will see all sorts of subtleties, all sorts of features in the very near future.
But we see how Latino voters really made an impact, and they made a big impact. That is, they became the same swing voters who now led the Democratic Party to victory. And this, of course, is connected primarily with ICE (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement), with the actions of the migration service. This is also due to the fact that there is great dissatisfaction and disappointment in the Latin American community due to the failure of Donald Trump to carry out immigration reform, as he promised.
And, of course, I would pay attention to individual districts in Florida where politicians, Republicans of Cuban origin are losing or barely holding on, with great difficulty holding on in those districts where Donald Trump won by 12 percentage points, somewhere around 15 percentage points. Thus, in Doral County in Florida, a classic Republican of Cuban origin is losing to a Democrat who was called a democratic socialist. Where Cubans vote, the socialists [usually] don't win. So once again, this is a loss for MAGA-Trumpism. This is very important to understand. Voters are sending a very clear signal that this is the loss of this particular brand of MAGA Trumpism by Donald Trump. I wonder, of course, what the Republican Party will do about this.
“Investigation, investigation, investigation.” About the Democrats' plan
BBC: You said that the main reason for the success of the Democrats is the failure of a particular brand of republican ideology. But what do the Democrats offer and what is their plan now that they have a majority in both Congress and the Senate, both chambers of the main US legislative body?
A.F.: Investigation, investigation, investigation and investigation again. First of all, this is what we, of course, will definitely see in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. A very short message was sent by Congressman Robert Garcia. On his [social media account] X, he wrote: “get lawyers.” Dot. And pinned this message to my X. This is really very important. He is the ranking member of the House Oversight Committee. And he will likely become chairman of the House Oversight Committee. This is what we will see: investigations, investigations and investigations. Returning to the very points that I listed: the second thing that worries voters is the future of democracy.
We will see hearings, demands for documents, subpoenas to testify. All issues that are related to abuse, potential abuse, corporate abuse, the Epstein case, cryptocurrency projects, that's what will be investigated first. And this is definitely the exact plan of the Democrats. Plus, of course, Hakeem Jeffries, who will be the head of the House of Representatives, the head of the Democratic majority. He promises to push for the restoration of expired health insurance subsidies, which we know as Obamacare.
And it must be said that here, too, it is worth paying attention to how Barack Obama introduced Abdul El-Sayed, speaking with him in Michigan, speaking with him during a campaign rally. And this is very important. This is the first time that the Democratic establishment, such an old, classic Democratic establishment, has bet on the left wing of the Democratic Party. There is some trickiness in this, because how did Barack Obama introduce Abdul El-Sayed? As a continuator of his business. He introduced Abdul El-Sayed as a new stage of the Democratic Party. “The man who will continue our work,” said Barack Obama. And Abdul El-Sayed agreed with him. He wrote on his X, later publishing a video with Barack Obama: “He started, and we will continue.” It's all about healthcare. What is the trick here that I mentioned? This is an attempt to take over, to “de-establish,” let me use this expression, the left wing of the Democratic Party, to move them a little away from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Bernie Sanders, from this wing, to bring them a little closer to the establishment, to the center.
Therefore, the stated legislative goals are medicine and the restoration of subsidies. Hakim Jeffries also spoke about the investigation into the Trump family's business, the alleged conflict of interest, and so on. And everything that concerns, of course, the budget, strict control over the budget. Both chambers get the opportunity to bargain with the White House on the terms of government funding. This is, of course, very important.
BBC: How did Trump react to this defeat of the Republican Party and will his plan, already announced, to veto all the bills he doesn’t like that Congress will consider and approve work?
A.F.: Donald Trump acknowledged the result. Donald Trump congratulated the Democrats - and at the same time he said that he has the right of veto. Donald Trump behaved very carefully. Now the White House has a full day planned for the president to meet with advisers. There they will work out how to respond to this landslide Democratic victory and decide how to proceed.
I want to remind you that, in fact, we will live with the old Congress for two more months, with a Republican majority, until January 3. After all, congressmen will now return to Washington on November 9. But this will be the old Congress with Mike Johnson at the head of the House of Representatives, and he will decide what to put forward for a vote and what not, how to limit Trump, how not to. So, of course, the White House now has a window of opportunity. It is never worth extrapolating historical examples to our current situation.
But nevertheless, it is still worth remembering that in 1998, Clinton made the decision to use military force against Iraq at a time when the Democratic Party had lost the midterm elections and the case of his impeachment, the impeachment of Bill Clinton, was already being considered. So yes, there are various historical precedents for this time, even when the president still maintains his party in Congress as well. So there may be different options for the development of events. This will now be discussed in the White House.
But for now, at the moment that we are talking to you, Donald Trump is behaving very carefully, acting very carefully. To override a veto in a vote of the full House of Representatives, 290 congressional votes are needed. To override a veto in the Senate, 67 votes of senators are needed. There won't be such a majority. That is, we do not see such a transition as after Watergate, after Watergate the Democratic Party had the opportunity to override a veto by voting strictly along party lines. This won't happen now, though. But nevertheless, the chances of overcoming the veto are great.
If the Republican Party wants to recover, if the Republican Party wants to remind again that this is not necessarily the party of Donald Trump, then they will need to, among other things, switch to the side of the Democrats, and sometimes override Donald Trump's veto if he vetoes it.
I would draw attention to Senator John Curtis, who addressed the Republicans, and he expresses the opinion of many anti-Trump Republicans who are in the Senate, including in the House of Representatives, of course, and even more so outside Congress. He wrote in his X: “It’s time for Republicans to return to the principled, conservative values that once defined us and from which we have gradually drifted away over the past decade.” The last 10 years, of course, since 2016, is, of course, Trumpism. That's what some Republicans are calling for now. So yes, overcoming a presidential veto is quite possible, but all sorts of impeachments are also quite possible.
Is Trump at risk of impeachment?
BBC: This is exactly what I wanted to ask. Is Trump at risk of impeachment, given this whole congressional mess you just described?
A.F.: On the one hand, we can say that in order to shake off Trump’s legacy, it is really necessary to carry out impeachment and thus restore the Republican Party. Thus, take all steps to ensure that the Republican Party regains its strength. And maybe this impeachment even needs to be led by Republicans.
But at the same time, we understand that, of course, a democrat will not magically appear. Then J.D. Vance will be in the White House, he will take the place of Donald Trump, and then President Vance will have every opportunity to explain how Donald Trump is to blame, how bad things were for Donald Trump, and how J.D. Vance was against the war with Iran, and we know that. We know that J.D. Vance is one of the very few in the Donald Trump administration who was against this Operation Epic Fury. So what happens then? The Democrats will give J.D. Vance such a wonderful opportunity: firstly, to become president and thus gain full access to all resources - informational in the first place - and the opportunity to explain and blame Donald Trump for everything. I'm not sure the Democrats will agree to this.
And the second point. I return again to the beginning of our conversation with you, to those same interests - that Americans are interested in the economy, the future of democracy, immigration policy, healthcare. And the issue of Trump’s impeachment is not an economic issue, not a question about the future of democracy. Waste time, waste energy, spend money, in the end, on impeachment instead of dealing with the economy? Will democratic voters support this decision of the Democrats? Will those same Latino swing voters support? This is the decision of the Democratic Party: is it necessary to spend time and energy on this if there is a chance that, after all, maybe they won’t vote in the Senate? Declaring impeachment is a simple matter. Declare impeachment on January 3, please. Oh, it's Sunday. Okay, Monday, January 4th, please. In the House of Representatives it’s easy, there are absolutely no problems. In the House of Representatives, a simple majority of 218 votes is needed. But to carry out impeachment and get 67 votes in the Senate - the big question is whether they will be able to carry it out. And they will spend a lot of effort and a lot of time on this. So I doubt Trump’s impeachment, but Pete Hegseth’s [impeachment] is very possible.
BBC: Well, then let's briefly remind our listeners who Pete Hegseth is. And most importantly, what he is accused of based on the leaks that have recently appeared in the American media.
A.F.: And not only leaks. Thom Tillis, a senator who, by the way, is leaving the Senate because Donald Trump supported not him, but his opponent, a MAGA-Trumpist, and the seat was lost... Thom Tillis has already proposed impeachment for [Secretary of Defense] Pete Hegseth, this for the head of the Pentagon. And the first points are related to the war with Iran. The first points are related to Operation Epic Fury, which, according to Thom Tillis and some Republicans, was carried out contrary to American law and against decisions of Congress. So these points are related to the war with Iran.
It is quite possible that all this will be carried out and carried out through the House of Representatives, through the Senate. This is where, it seems to me, it is quite possible that there will be votes, and Donald Trump may well be happy for the Democrats and all Americans to let off steam in this way. That is, not in connection with the impeachment of Donald Trump, but in connection with the impeachment of Pete Hegseth, because all the dogs can be blamed on him, as they say, accusing him of the fact that the idea of a war with Iran was correct, but the execution was bad. And, accordingly, in this way we can somehow divert the thunder from ourselves a little. So I think there may be some voices here.
Of course, this does not mean at all that these decisions will be made. Therefore, we are entering such a slightly alarming period. The window of opportunity for a new round of strikes on Iran opens right now and closes exactly on January 3, when they can begin discussing the impeachment of Pete Hegseth.
What the Republican Defeat Means for Ukraine and Russia
BBC: You have already touched on the topic of foreign policy. And I have seen the view that since the Democratic-majority Congress will now primarily focus on domestic policy, Trump himself will increasingly look beyond the US border and engage in foreign policy. Do you agree with this opinion? And if so, what will this mean for Russia and Ukraine?
AF: On the one hand, the Trump administration and the Trump team will come to negotiations in Abu Dhabi, if they really happen, in a slightly weakened form. Because all the investigations that we talked about will be primarily against Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff - in connection with the failure to comply with the Lindsey Graham law, in connection with the diesel deal with Russia. That's what the investigations will be about. That is, the political power of those people who should represent the United States in Abu Dhabi will be reduced.
But at the same time, Melania Trump literally tomorrow is going to organize a meeting in the White House of representatives of Ukraine and representatives of Russia in order to explore the possibility of conducting the same humanitarian missions like Alyoshek. First of all, she will congratulate everyone, of course, but there will also be a discussion. This center of negotiating power may move directly to the White House. And it will be important for Donald Trump to show that his family is engaged in this negotiation track, his family is engaged in this humanitarian mission. Not just any diplomats, but Jared Kushner is his family too. But still, Steve Witkoff was number one in the negotiation process. So this is an important element. Perhaps, on the contrary, the center of power will be there, attention will be there, I mean in the White House, I mean Melania Trump. And for Donald Trump, for his rating and to protect himself a little, it would be good to carry out another mission like Alyoshek, like a ceasefire there. So the focus on such local ceasefire issues, I think, will remain. At least it seems that political technology would be good for them.
image copyrightGetty Images
Then the next question, which no one will object to, is the question of concluding a new START treaty. New START-4 or something else, it will be called the “Strategic Offensive Arms Treaty,” but with China. Donald Trump spoke about denuclearization. Who is against denuclearization? Who is against nuclear arms control? Nobody is against it except China. China doesn't want to do this at all. China has always been categorically against any negotiations on nuclear weapons, on limiting itself to nuclear weapons. And at the same time, China has not yet overtaken the United States in the number of nuclear weapons, but in five years it will certainly catch up. So it is quite possible that some kind of negotiations are related to Trump's presidential legacy of this kind. Nuclear weapons, denuclearization.
This is what we will quite possibly see. And the focus of attention may very well be there - just to get additional political points and protect yourself a little.
BBC: Then let's summarize. It turns out, if I understand your words correctly, that Trump is unlikely to wave his hand and fly off in a helicopter from the White House lawn, as Nixon did. On the one side. But on the other hand, his hands will be tied, at least in part, as far as domestic policy is concerned. Then what awaits him in this very White House in the next two years?
AF: When we talk about Trump, I would not rule out anything, including waving a hand from the new White House lawn, where Donald Trump installed a new special helicopter pad. Now all this will be decided. Perhaps Donald Trump will turn 180 degrees, and we have seen that. Let's remember how Donald Trump communicated with Zohran Mamdani, how he called Mamdani, the mayor of New York, simply a communist who is leading New York into the abyss. And at that moment, when they met in the White House, Donald Trump smiled and shook Zohran Mamdani’s hand with great pleasure. So such 180-degree turns are quite possible. Exactly in order to protect himself and his family from any investigations overtaking him. It is quite possible that Donald Trump will have just such an agreement with the Democrats. You are not investigating me and such and such people, but I am going to meet you halfway. And I'm not vetoing your bills and your decisions, including health care and Obamacare, and tariffs, for example, and not applying more tariffs. It may very well be that Donald Trump will have just such an agreement.
In any case, quite interesting times await us. And now the important element for Democrats will be not only to win now, at a time when people are voting against the Republican Party, but to maintain this victory and do something with it - to actually pass some legislation and actually make some decisions, primarily in relation to the economy. The question here will be whether the Republican Party will be ready to completely turn away from the legacy of Trump and Trumpism and, perhaps, work with the Democrats. Or, on the contrary, he will try in every possible way to reduce the influence of the Democratic Party by independently passing some legislation and being leaders, leaders, the driving force behind those bills that concern Americans, namely healthcare, the economy, and so on. While the Democrats are mired in investigations and impeachments.
BBC: What does the outcome of this election mean for the presidential campaign that awaits us in two years?
A.F.: It has begun. This is the first one. Of course, it is very interesting what will happen next. We will see results from the Latino vote, and this will probably be decisive for Marco Rubio whether he will participate in the 2028 elections. Perhaps not the wisest decision right now. It might be beneficial for Marco Rubio to sit out two years. Of course, you can’t sit out the post of Secretary of State. In general, if we separate the actions of Donald Trump from the actions of Marco Rubio as Secretary of State, we will see that Secretary of State Marco Rubio is very, very successful, especially in Latin American countries. So it may well be best for him to wait and remain Secretary of State until 2028 and then, after waiting four years, run for the presidency and try to run for the Republican nomination.
J.D. Vance does not have such an opportunity to somehow sit out, so to speak. Still, he is more connected with Donald Trump, he is more connected with this administration. And it is unknown how he will act now. But still, at the moment, the main contenders today seem to remain J.D. Vance and Marco Rubio. There are, of course, others outside the Donald Trump administration who would be willing to try. It is the Republicans who are not currently associated with the Donald Trump administration who are the most unexpected characters.
BBC: And the Democrats?
A.F.: The Democrats have a huge field, absolutely gigantic. It’s worth looking at least at the winners we see now. Jon Ossoff in Georgia seems to be the obvious candidate. Barack Obama came to support him in Georgia, although it was already clear: Jon Ossoff had a lead of more than 15 percentage points. That is, it would seem that there is no need to waste time coming to Georgia and supporting John. No, Barack Obama did it - with a view to 2028, absolutely. And, of course, James Talarico, Texas, is a conservative Democrat, that is, a Democrat from Texas, also a very interesting figure. Well, of course, we, of course, must not forget Gavin Newsom, the governor of California, he is no longer the governor of California, and he has all the time to engage in the election campaign. Jay Pritzker, Governor of Illinois - he expressed interest, and many many others. The Democrats have a huge set, a huge field in which to think about who will be the candidate from the Democratic Party.
End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletter
Download the new BBC World Service app!
When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.
Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




