Tortures, "burnings", deportations, forced disappearances... Can we compare the massacres committed by France in its former colonies to that perpetrated by the Nazis on June 10, 1944 in Oradour-sur-Glane? For the political scientist Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison, who devotes his latest work to this question at the heart of a media-political controversy in February 2025, historians have decided a long time ago.
Published on: 04/19/2026 - 09:56
“Every year, in France, we commemorate what happened in Oradour-sur-Glane, that is to say the massacre of an entire village. But we have done hundreds of them in Algeria. Are we aware of it?” On February 25, 2025, the French journalist Jean-Michel Aphatie uttered this sentence in his column on RTL, provoking a controversy of unspeakable violence. He is then accused of "not loving France": Jordan Bardella, president of the National Rally, accuses him of "odiously falsifying history", Éric Ciotti (Union of Rights for the Republic, UDR) of making "indigenist propaganda", Cyril Hanouna, leader of Vincent Bolloré's group of "comparing France to Nazi Germany"... Faced with political-media lynching, and after his suspension by the management from RTL, Jean-Michel Aphatie decides to leave the radio, despite the support of many historians.
Read also Massacre of Oradour-sur-Glane: 80 years later, gray areas remain
For Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison, professor of political science and political philosophy at Paris-Saclay University, this “scandal” marks “the triumph of the prejudices of national republican mythology over historical truth”. Did France commit massacres of civilians comparable to this symbol of Nazi barbarism during its colonial conquest in the 19th and 20th centuries? This is what Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison wants to demonstrate in "French colonial Oradour. Against the 'national novel'" (ed. Les Liens qui Libération). The political scientist details how the national novel, "this reputedly glorious story of French history", made it possible to conceal and deny "the extreme brutality of French colonization".
France 24: Why this title, “French colonial Oradour”? Is it to shock?
Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison: That is not the aim of the book. It is a question of reestablishing historical truths established for a very long time. The reference to Oradour arose very early after the Second World War, notably with the intervention in December 1945 of a deputy from the Algerian Communist Party in the National Constituent Assembly (Algeria was then still a French territory, which sent deputies to the Assembly in Paris, Editor's note.)
From May 8, 1945, there were terrible massacres in Algeria – the death toll was between 30,000 and 35,000. Civilians were massacred by the French army and by colonial militias, and the corpses were sometimes burned in lime kilns to make them disappear. These techniques of terror and massacres have little to envy of the methods used by the “Das Reich” division in Oradour-sur-Glane.
Furthermore, during the conquest of Algeria by General Bugeaud, there were episodes that were perfectly known and studied. General Bugeaud gives the following order to his officers who are preparing to leave for the campaign: "If these scoundrels (the natives, Editor's note) retire to their cave, smoke them like foxes." This order was applied in particular by General Pélissier, who carried out a “firefight” exterminating an entire tribe of 1,000 people – unarmed men, women, children and old men. Here again, we are entitled to consider that these are indeed massacres equivalent to that of Oradour.
After the start of the last Algerian war, on November 1, 1954, resistance fighters also referred to the "Algerian Gestapo". For them, the methods used by the French army were equivalent in terms of torture to those of the German Gestapo. They used the term “French Gestapo” to describe these torture practices and, obviously, to denounce them.
Read alsoMaurice Audin affair: a historic request for forgiveness, a step forward for Algeria
Is revisiting its colonial history a French particularity?
The debate does not oppose two interpretations of history. It pits those who are attached to the establishment of knowledge and truth against those who defend what constitutes a national novel. This imperial republican mythology euphemizes the crimes committed, or even completely denies them. This is indeed a desire to falsify and maintain a national mythology.
France presents a certain particularity. If we compare with Great Britain, Germany, Canada and the United States, all these states have recognized in one way or another the crimes committed during the colonial period or against indigenous populations (the British government expressed "sincere regrets" for the repression of the Mau Mau insurgency in Kenya, in the 1950s; Germany apologized in 2021 for "the genocide" of the Herero and Nama tribes in Namibia, etc. Editor’s note). In some cases, the courts have granted financial reparations to victims or their descendants. The comparison reveals the extraordinary French “backwardness” linked to the persistent pusillanimity of political authorities, right or left.
Also read October 17, 1961: a massacre of Algerians in the heart of Paris
Is there an Algerian particularity or were these methods used in all French colonies?
Overall, there are many similarities between the methods of terror warfare imposed on the natives in the different territories of the Empire. Indochina and the Algerian War present a particularity: it is there that the doctrine of counter-revolutionary war is implemented. The practices of torture and forced disappearance are theorized and implemented, today qualified as crimes against humanity. The French armed forces, under the authority of political power, deported two and a half million Algerian civilians, placed in regroupment camps in order to empty entire regions of their population. The objective was to deprive the FLN (the National Liberation Front founded in October 1954 to fight against colonization, Editor's note) of all military and logistical support. Mass terror techniques were used after the Algerian War, particularly in Cameroon.
Crime against humanity is defined in the French penal code. Torture and enforced disappearance are considered crimes against humanity when the motives are ethnic, racial or political. The military acted under a perfectly concerted plan, developed by the military and desired and supported by the politicians. These methods were part of their mission to “pacify” Algeria.
Also read: Algerians, French: they recount their Algerian war
“Pacification” is not taught much in France. Is this a desire to conceal the colonial conquest?
“Pacification” is the official term used by the political and military authorities at the time of the conquest of Algeria, after the appointment of General Bugeaud to the post of governor general. He suggests that the objective of colonization is to bring peace to the populations who will be conquered and dominated and thus to create the conditions for the development of these colonies. The events, the chronology, the responsibility of the military and politicians are perfectly established by very important works. The problem comes rather from the secondary education programs, which give very little importance to the conquest of Algeria and more broadly to the colonial history of France.
However, there have been significant advances in the content of school textbooks. I am thinking in particular of the question of slavery and the Code Noir of 1685. The problem is that secondary school teachers are constrained by schedules and limited. Today, middle and high school students know little or nothing about the colonial history of France.
See also Algerian War: rape of women, a subject still taboo
In 2017, Emmanuel Macron spoke of “crimes against humanity” during a visit to Algeria. After his election, these terms disappeared from his speech. Has he given in to the national novel?
This statement was made as a candidate and not as President of the Republic. As soon as he returned to Paris, he partially retracted these statements. Getting involved in this area would have posed problems for him in the presidential election. This is also why as head of state, he did nothing to move forward on the question of recognition of the colonial crimes committed during the colonization of Algeria. Macron has continued to evolve on these issues. Since the law of February 23, 2005, the National Rally (and its predecessor, the National Front, Editor's note) and the radicalized rights have continued to defend the French imperial past: François Fillon, Bruno Retailleau and Édouard Philippe.
Read alsoIn Algeria, Macron calls for looking to the future despite a “painful” past
In your opinion, did this law of February 23, 2005 on the “positive role of colonization” constitute a turning point?
This is a very significant turning point. This is the moment when, for reasons of electoral competition, the right-wing majority, that is to say the UMP chaired by Nicolas Sarkozy, decides to defend positions of rehabilitation of the French colonial past which have, in fact, been those of the National Front for a very long time.
This is a double exception. On the one hand, because France is the only former colonial power to have passed such a law. On the other hand, because the State cannot intervene in the human sciences and in particular history. It must be remembered that this involves establishing an interpretation that is both official and apologetic of the French colonial past. It is a completely illiberal position and an attack on the essential autonomy of the human sciences in general, and of history in particular.
Read alsoAlgerian War: Sarkozy tackles Hollande on the commemoration of March 19
As a historian, do you think that France must make peace with its past? Algiers demands "repentance"...
We do not make peace with a past, but possibly with formerly colonized states, Algeria in particular. This obviously involves recognizing the crimes committed during colonization. At a minimum, these crimes must be considered to be state crimes and crimes against humanity.
These requests from Algeria are subject to both internal and diplomatic considerations which have little to do with a concern for historical truth. It is about using history as a political-diplomatic resource. In France, those who work for the recognition of crimes never use this moral and religious vocabulary. This is a political and legal question.
See alsoFrantz Fanon: from Martinique to Algeria, his fights against colonialism
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




