French lawmakers are scheduled to debate this Thursday a bill that proposes classifying as anti-Semitic any form of "hatred" implicitly expressed against the State of Israel, which would make it a crime under the country's anti-terrorism laws. Critics of the so-called "Yadan law" warn that the new legislation could not only silence legitimate criticism of Israel, but also fuel anti-Semitism in France

First modification: 04/16/2026 - 12:06 Last modification: 04/16/2026 - 12:08

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

French lawmakers are scheduled to vote this Thursday on a government-backed bill based on the idea that the rise of anti-Semitism in the country with Europe's largest Jewish population is based on an "obsessive" hatred of Israel.

The legislation has been drafted and amended several times since it was first presented to the National Assembly in late 2024.

Previous versions would have banned any comparison between Israel and Nazi Germany as a "trivialization" of the Holocaust, and banned public speeches calling for the ill-defined "denial" of the existence of a state.

If passed in its current form, the law will expand the definition of "apology for terrorism"—defending or justifying terrorist acts, considered a crime in France—to include expressions that "implicitly" justify or minimize acts considered terrorist.

The law would also make it illegal to call for the "destruction" of any country recognized by France, with penalties of up to five years in prison.

The project's preamble leaves little room for doubt about which country its authors have in mind:

“Today, anti-Jewish hatred in our country is fueled by an obsessive hatred of Israel, whose very existence is regularly delegitimized and criminalized,” the text states.

“This hatred towards the State of Israel is now inseparable from hatred towards the Jews,” the law adds.

The proposal — dubbed the “Yadan law” in reference to MP Caroline Yadan, who introduced it — has divided the National Assembly. Critics argue that this is a misguided attempt to combat anti-Semitism that could backfire, even fueling more hatred against the Jewish community.

A petition on the National Assembly's official website against the project had gathered more than 160,000 signatures as of Friday.

France has seen a sharp increase in anti-Semitic acts since the Hamas-led terrorist attacks on October 7, 2023 and the Israeli military campaign in the Gaza Strip. In 2025, more than half of all reported anti-religious acts targeted the Jewish community.

However, the 2024 annual report of France's National Advisory Commission on Human Rights on the fight against racism, anti-Semitism and xenophobia indicated that its surveys have found no statistically significant relationship between having a negative view of the political or religious ideology of Zionism and anti-Semitic prejudice.

“It is therefore difficult to consider anti-Zionism as the main driver of contemporary anti-Semitism,” the report notes.

Left-wing lawmakers — from leaders of the Socialist Party to the Greens and France Insoumise — have criticized the law as an attempt to silence legitimate criticism of the Israeli government by defining it as inherently anti-Semitic.

The far-right National Rally, the conservative Republicans party, the center-right bloc and some members of the Socialist Party, including former president François Hollande, have backed the project.

The French government has openly expressed its support for the law — and its position that opposing the creation of a Jewish state in formerly Palestinian territory is, in essence, anti-Semitic.

During the 40th annual dinner of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions of France in February, Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu said the government would put the project — first presented by Yadan in 2024 — to a vote in the spring, arguing that the country needs new laws to confront what he described as a new form of hatred against the Jewish community in France.

“Contemporary anti-Zionism has become the mask of an old anti-Semitism,” he said, in line with the spirit of the bill.

Lecornu added that calls for a free Palestine "from the river to the sea" — a common slogan among activists — constitute an explicit call for the destruction of Israel, since they refer to its territory. Activists maintain that this is a demand for freedom for those who live on historically Palestinian lands.

Although Lecornu affirmed that criticizing the Israeli government and its military actions is legitimate, he accused those who describe Israel's war in Gaza as a "genocide" of "stripping Jews of their history and transforming them from victims into executioners."

"Talking about 'genocide' in Gaza erases their memory of the Holocaust," he declared. "It minimizes it and inverts it."

An earlier version of the bill proposed making it illegal to compare Israel to Nazi Germany — an article that was removed on the recommendation of the Conseil d'État, France's highest administrative court.

The International Court of Justice warned in 2024 that Israel's military campaign in Gaza could plausibly constitute genocide. A UN commission of inquiry went further the following year, calling Israel's actions in the Palestinian territory genocidal in nature.

"Dangerous"

Nathalie Tehio, president of the French Human Rights League – a staunch opponent of the project – warned that legally linking the protection of the Jewish community in France with the protection of the State of Israel could actually fuel anti-Semitism rather than combat it.

"In practice, it equates French Jews with Israel — which is dangerous in itself, since that very equivalence fuels anti-Semitism," he said. "But it also gives the impression that there is a double standard, because it is a law that addresses anti-Semitism while acting as a defense of Israel, so there is a double risk of reinforcing anti-Semitism."

Other critics have questioned what they describe as overly broad or vague wording, making it difficult to predict which statements might or might not violate the new legislation.

The French Lawyers' Union warned in January that criminalizing statements that "implicitly" justify or incite terrorist acts would, in practice, turn judges into a kind of "thought police."

Some have also questioned the very need for such a law.

François Dubuisson, professor of international law at the Free University of Brussels, noted that France already has a comprehensive set of laws against inciting racial hatred and against “apology” for terrorism.

"In my opinion, the legislation in force in France is sufficient, because what remains in the amended version of the project - after taking into account the opinion of the Conseil d'État - is mainly an expansion of the crime of advocacy of terrorism," he explained.

"But it is important to note that, even under current legislation, this crime is extremely broad and, in fact, is the subject of strong criticism from various international human rights organizations."

Since the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, the French law on "apology for terrorism" has been used to subpoena hundreds of left-wing activists, trade unionists, researchers and politicians to testify before the police for statements related to the attacks.

Rima Hassan, a radical left MEP, was taken into police custody on Thursday, accused of justifying terrorism in a social media post that cited a far-left Japanese militant implicated in a deadly attack on Lod airport in 1972. Hassan, who later deleted the post, has been summoned to testify in 16 cases, of which 13 have been filed without charge.

Dubuisson said the need for a law prohibiting calls for the destruction of a state is even less clear.

"To my knowledge, this does not exist anywhere in the world," he said. "I am not aware of any legislation – and even less so in Europe – that contemplates a crime of this type."

He argued that calls for the violent destruction of a State and its population would already leave the perpetrator exposed to a set of existing laws that criminalize incitement to violence.

And although the text's preamble specifically mentions Israel, the current wording would also cover calls for the destruction of the State of Palestine, which France recognized in September last year — a decision that led Yadan to leave French President Emmanuel Macron's parliamentary group.

Tehio stressed that the existence of Israel as a Jewish state remains the subject of intense debate, even among anti-Zionist Jews who defend what is known as a “one-state solution”: Israelis and Palestinians sharing a single state with full and equal rights for all.

“There are those who, for example, consider that there should be a single State that brings together both Israel and the Palestinian State,” he explained.

What kind of statements the law would ultimately sanction remains deeply uncertain. Tehio noted that the French prime minister's example — the direct call for the destruction of Israel with the slogan "from the river to the sea" — can also be heard among far-right Israeli activists, although in very different contexts.

"Those who use that expression will be effectively sanctioned, because it will be interpreted as implying either the destruction of the Palestinian State or the Israeli State," he stated. "But that doesn't really make sense."

This text is adapted from the English article originally published on April 4, 2026

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.