image copyrightIra L. Black / Corbis / MOHD RASFAN / Kristina Solovyova / POOL / AFP via Getty Images

During a recent visit to an exhibition at the Manege on Moscow's Red Square with a group of schoolchildren, Russian President Vladimir Putin stopped in front of a large sculpture of British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, American President Franklin D. Roosevelt and USSR Prime Minister Joseph Stalin at the February 1945 Yalta Conference.

"These were the leaders of the three major powers, who met to discuss how the world should be organized after the war," Putin told the children on November 4.

The day before, China's Foreign Ministry and the Kremlin had announced consultations for a meeting between Putin, US President Donald Trump and the president of China. Xi Jinping, on November 18 and 19, within the framework of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen.

White House spokeswoman Olivia Wales confirmed the meeting would take place.

When the first reports emerged in mid-October that the Kremlin was proposing such a meeting, there was immediate concern in the European Union and Ukraine, with many recalling the meeting of the leaders of the anti-Hitler coalition at the former residence of the Russian tsars on the shores of the Black Sea, in Yalta.

In exchange for Stalin's agreement to enter the war against Japan following the victory over Germany, an expansion of Soviet influence in Eastern Europe was accepted, and a secret agreement in East Asia granted the USSR Japanese territories south of Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands, while reestablishing the Soviet naval base in the Chinese city of Port Arthur and recognizing special economic interests in Manchuria.

Since then, in Eastern Europe, "Yalta" became shorthand for a cynical agreement between great powers that divided the world into spheres of influence without regard for smaller countries, including those whose territories they were dividing.

image copyrightGetty Images

"I absolutely do not want this to become a Yalta Two, Three or Four, where influence is simply redistributed," Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said of this week's meeting.

End of Most read

"After Alaska, this would mark a second major diplomatic victory for Russia if events unfold as Russian officials currently suggest regarding their desire for a new 'Yalta,'" he added.

Meanwhile, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz noted that any debate on how to end the war in Ukraine must involve Europe.

"Europe must and wants to play a role in this process," he emphasized.

"The key issues for a peace agreement, whether sanctions or the future security architecture, can only be resolved with the participation of Europeans, and all participants know this," he said.

"Unusual format"

While it is true that Putin could be trying to rally support to end the war in Ukraine on terms favorable to Russia, as The Wall Street Journal reports, it is still unclear what exactly he wants to discuss with Trump and Xi.

"Ukraine will inevitably emerge in one form or another," admitted Yuri Ushakov, a Russian presidential adviser.

However, he added: "So far, there are only preliminary outlines of what could be discussed at such a high level and in such an unusual format."

Trump has denied that Ukraine is on the agenda, saying instead: "We could meet to talk about nuclear weapons and nuclear disarmament."

image source, Reuters

And China does not want to engage in talks on Ukraine that exclude Europe, as it is doing everything it can to undermine the perception that it supports Russia in the war, according to Joseph Torigian, an associate professor at American University in Washington.

Although Chinese elites have increasingly sidelined the European Union in recent years, they remain interested in maintaining good relations with European countries as key trading partners.

But Beijing is also skeptical of nuclear weapons negotiations, Torigian notes.

"They believe that, by having a smaller nuclear program, one of its advantages is its opacity," he says.

'Bringing peace'

Russia's interest in such a meeting is obvious: to exclude Europe from the negotiations on Ukraine and demonstrate, once again, that Moscow cannot be isolated on the international stage.

The appeal to the US leader is also evident.

"Trump is excited about this because of the pomp and atmosphere," Torigian said.

"He will be able to tell the story of how wonderful it is that these great powers have come together, that he was the first person to do it and that he is bringing peace," he adds.

image copyrightEPA

All the news you need is on BBC World Service

Download it here

End of Ad app

But for Beijing, the benefits are much less clear.

"Yalta is not a pleasant memory for the Chinese," says Torigian.

They were outraged that Stalin had secured special Soviet interests in Manchuria.

"Even Mao Zedong, after the communist victory in China in 1949, thought that everything the Soviets asked for in Yalta and what they continued to demand was a very delicate issue," recalls the expert.

These disputes partly explain the subsequent rupture between China and the USSR.

As far as Eastern Europe is concerned, historians still debate the extent to which the expansion of the Soviet sphere of influence was simply the acceptance of an inevitable reality.

By February 1945, the Red Army already occupied Romania, Bulgaria and much of Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

But today, the Russian military does not even control all of the territory in eastern Ukraine that the Kremlin has already claimed as Russian, and unlike in 1945, only one of the potential summit participants is directly involved in the war.

International prestige

According to Torigian, Russia is also the only country that remains interested in a clear division of the world into spheres of influence.

Even though the National Security Strategy adopted under the Trump administration describes the Western Hemisphere as an American sphere of influence, the United States is unwilling to abandon its support for Taiwan.

And China's presence in Latin America continues to be important for Beijing.

Russia considers itself a superpower on par with the United States and China—and official Chinese statements often describe Russia as an equal—“but behind closed doors, neither Chinese experts nor Chinese leaders consider Russia an equal power to them,” says Marcin Kaczmarski of the University of Glasgow.

"The only country that Chinese leaders and elites consider truly on par with China is the United States," he notes.

According to Kaczmarski, a trilateral summit could enhance Beijing's international prestige by presenting Xi as a go-to global statesman for the heads of other great powers.

Image source, AFP

But Trump's position on the world stage has also become less secure following the Republicans' defeat in the US midterm elections.

The question is whether China wants to strengthen its international position, Kaczmarski says, adding: "I still have a lot of doubts about the meeting itself."

During his visits to Eastern Europe in the 2000s, then-US President George W. Bush repeatedly called the Yalta agreements a historic evil.

They were comments specifically directed at Putin, according to The New York Times, to tell him that Russia had no right to interfere in the affairs of its neighbors and that it should apologize for the actions of the USSR.

"No more Yaltas," Bush declared in Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania, in 2002.

If, almost 25 years later, Putin manages to arrange a meeting with the leaders of the United States and China in a format that even remotely resembles the Yalta Conference, it will be a symbolic victory for him, even if the meeting itself does not produce concrete results.

This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.

Discover more

Video

End of Video

Top news

Why the historic summit between Trump, Putin and Xi worries Europe (and what it could mean for the rest of the world)

What was the sophisticated attack with which Ukraine destroyed part of Putin's prized Crimean bridge (and what consequences will it have)?

Xi receives Trump and Putin in Shenzhen, China's "city of dreams": this is what they won't see

Don't miss it

Most popular readings