Israel declared on October 1 that 170 Palestinian journalists killed in Gaza were in reality "terrorists" from Hamas and other armed groups in Gaza. But according to our analysis, this assessment differs from the accounts of the main organizations defending journalists. These organizations also denounce insufficiently founded accusations by the Israeli army.

Published on: 02/11/2026 - 17:06

“For almost three years, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) have been accused of targeting journalists in Gaza. Today we reveal the truth.” On October 1, on

On an online page entitled "Press Files", the army details for each of the 170 people what it considers to be evidence: photos, funeral tributes from Hamas, extracts from spreadsheets. In this list, we find well-known names, such as Anas al-Sharif, star journalist of Al Jazeera killed on August 10, 2025 by Israel, or correspondent Hossam Shabat, killed by an Israeli drone in March 2025.

A considerable figure when compared to the results of the Gaza government media office, managed by Hamas, which counted 263 journalists killed as of October 1.

191 Gaz journalists killed since October 2023 according to CPJ

The numerous censuses of journalists killed in Gaza in reality diverge greatly, between those of the Gazan authorities and those of regional or international organizations.

To analyze it, the Observers editorial team compared the Israeli army's list with the counts of the three main international organizations defending journalists: the American organization Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), the French NGO Reporters Without Borders (RSF) and the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ).

As of October 31, CPJ counts 191 Palestinian journalists killed by Israel since the start of the war in Gaza. This toll, previously higher, was revised downwards in June and September 2026: according to CPJ, 27 people were removed after investigation for their involvement in fighting, and nine others after an internal investigation determined that they were not journalists.

Reporters Without Borders, which only takes into account journalists killed in the exercise of their function, has listed 63 journalists killed in Gaza since October 2023. It told our editorial staff that it had withdrawn five names during the summer, after establishing their affiliation with fighting groups. But the October Israeli publication did not modify its list: "We take these allegations seriously. But after verification, we see nothing new" in the Israeli army's publication, RSF explains to the France 24 Observers editorial team. "These are accusations that we have already seen and on which we have already worked."

The International Federation of Journalists, which works with the Palestinian Journalists' Union (PJS), for its part recorded 240 journalists killed on October 1, before adjusting its toll to 203 on October 14.

Of the 170 profiles identified by Israel, 37 of them were removed from at least one list of the three organizations, most often because they had participated in combat.

But conversely, 44 of the 170 names have never appeared on any list of these three organizations. As for the 89 names remaining in at least one of the three lists, the organizations currently consider the proof of their participation in the fighting insufficient.

Figures revised downwards by organizations

Why were these 37 names removed by the organizations? These withdrawals are mainly explained by the funeral tributes that Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad have published since the spring of 2026 to their fighters. Several dozen of them had previously been registered as journalists, as CheckNews, Libération's verification service, showed at the end of August.

In the list of combatant journalists, we find Mohammad Jarghoun, killed on October 7, 2023 at the start of the war. After a funeral tribute published in a Telegram loop from the armed wing of Hamas in June 2026, internal investigations within the CPJ and RSF concluded that he was affiliated with an armed movement and removed him from their lists. A withdrawal carried out before the Israeli army released, on October 1, 2026, photos of him armed and in military clothing.

Same thing for Mohammed Manhal Abu Armana, listed only by CPJ as a freelance photographer: after the publication of a Hamas obituary and a photo of him armed, the American organization removed him from its list last June, before the Israeli army published information about him.

The CPJ is transparent about the withdrawals made: in June and September 2026, it published the list of 27 people removed from its list because of their participation in the fighting and nine others for other reasons. “Each case in our database is independently confirmed, using information from at least two reliable sources,” says CPJ. Family members, colleagues, eyewitnesses, official investigations carried out by third parties: “CPJ never relies on a single unverified testimony,” indicates the American NGO.

The IFJ, which has listed 249 different names in its successive versions, has recorded, since October 14, 203 names. She took the longest to remove several dozen names from her list. And if a large part of the 46 names were removed after October 1, the IFJ assures that its internal investigations were already underway.

“We are withdrawing a name in two cases”, indicates the federation to the editorial staff of the Observers. “When we cannot establish with sufficient reliability that the person was a journalist, or when there is credible evidence that they participated directly in the fighting.”

Stating that she had done her "own documentation and verification work", she also declared that "an accusation or publication coming from a party to the conflict can be taken into account, but it is never enough alone to remove a name from our list". However, the organization did not specify the number of journalists ultimately considered as combatants.

In the eyes of the organizations, however, this type of investigation proves to be "exceptionally complex and unique", as the IFJ indicates to our editorial staff, "because no one can leave the Gaza Strip without Israeli authorization and no one can enter it. In particular journalists and the IFJ: we go to all the conflict zones in the world...except Gaza."

44 cases not recorded by international organizations

What about the remaining 133 names? According to our analysis, 44 have never been listed as journalists by these organizations. “A large part of the names published by the Israeli army were already outside the RSF list,” the organization told our editorial staff. “These names were already identified as non-journalists” – for example writers or people running a blog.

However, these names appear in other censuses: that of the government media office in Gaza managed by Hamas, or those of regional organizations, such as Gigaza, Stop Murdering Journalists or the Shireen Observatory. The organization run by volunteers still lists 332 media professionals killed as of October 31, including several people excluded by international organizations because of their participation in the fighting.

Accusations poorly documented by the army

The list of 170 people established by the Israeli army therefore includes 89 names of people whom at least one of the three international organizations continues to consider as journalists. Questioned by our editorial team, each judged the evidence provided by the Israeli army to be insufficient.

“That a party to the conflict presents a journalist as a member of an organization or as linked to one of the belligerents is not enough to call into question his status,” explains the IFJ. “These claims must be examined with caution and verified using reliable, if possible independent, evidence.”

A point also shared by the Israeli open-source investigative account X Middle East Buka: the person behind this account, Michael, has listed on X since 2025 elements from Palestinian sources indicating a possible affiliation of journalists with armed movements in Gaza. "I don't think the Israeli army's evidence can be used as evidence just because they used spreadsheet captures. Not because I don't believe it, but because I can't verify it."

For most of the cases removed from the lists, the army had published photos in military uniform or tributes from armed groups. For the remaining 89 names, the elements are thinner. In 38 cases, the army only invokes "multiple intelligence sources", without other proof.

This is the case of journalist Mahmoud Islim Al Basos, killed by Israel during the ceasefire in early 2025 while filming northern Gaza with a drone. His images taken from the sky were published by several international media. Since his death, the Israeli army has accused him of having used his drone for military purposes, without providing proof.

Same thing for Ibrahim Daher, killed by the Israeli army with journalist Anas al-Sharif in August 2025 and still listed by the three organizations. Based solely on "multiple intelligence sources", the army assures that he was an operator of the military branch of Hamas.

An accusation that is not very credible in the eyes of the CPJ, which indicates in its detailed file on the journalist that the Israeli army "has a long-standing habit of asserting without foundation that many of the journalists it deliberately killed in Gaza were terrorists."

For one name, Ahmed Bakr Mahmoud Al-Louh, listed by the three organizations, the army does not even mention the type of source used to declare that he belonged to the armed wing of Hamas.

For 31 other cases, the army published only a screenshot of documents allegedly from the Gazan armed movements, most often recovered in Gaza according to the army, but without specifying the origin or date of the document.

Hamza Al-Dahdouh, an Al-Jazeera journalist killed by Israel in January 2024 after a drone report, is still accused of having belonged to the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, on the basis of a document found in Gaza by the Israeli army which dates from 2022. Two experts interviewed by the BBC had at the time contested its authenticity.

In March 2024, a Washington Post investigation based on videos recovered from the drone and testimonies also called into question the Israeli version, which had claimed that the drone used threatened the Israeli army. In the images taken from the sky and broadcast by the American media, no army unit was visible.

“The biggest massacre of journalists”

These “allegations” are “based on intelligence sources without sufficient direct evidence,” the CPJ specifies to our editorial staff, which also rejects the accusations based “on documents allegedly recovered in Gaza,” which it considers “elements expressly described as unverified or evidence already known to the CPJ.”

Asked by our editorial staff, the Israeli army declared that it based these accusations "on information collected and analyzed by specialized authorities, in particular by cross-checking data from multiple sources. The information published concerning these journalists is based on reliable elements indicating their affiliation with terrorist organizations and their involvement in activities carried out on their behalf."

For the last 19 names still listed, the army has published photos or tributes. Elements which are also considered insufficient, considers the CPJ, due to lack of knowledge when and in what context the affiliation took place. Hassan Abu Warda thus remains on the American organization's list despite a tribute from Palestinian Islamic Jihad because five independent sources confirmed to CPJ that he worked as a journalist during the war without being involved in combat. The IFJ, however, removed it from its list.

In its methodology, CPJ recalls that it includes "journalists working for state-supported media outlets as well as those working for media outlets affiliated with militant groups, provided they do not participate in fighting or incite violence in a manner likely to have immediate consequences."

Michael, from the Middle East Buka account, still believes that the tributes are a serious element. “An official obituary stating that a person belonged to a military unit is proof of their affiliation. It is not necessarily proof that they were still serving at the time of their death, but it is not something I would ignore either.”

CPJ says it is investigating seven profiles, including five before the Israeli publication. For the rest, the organization clarified that the Israeli army "has not provided credible evidence to support the allegation that these people took an active part in the fighting."

In the coming months, the organizations' records could be revised again if new revelations emerge, with Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad continuing to post their tributes online. “But even with the most conservative figures, we are still witnessing the largest massacre of journalists committed by any army in recent history,” says RSF.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.