Paris (France) (AFP) – Having just reached the top of world tennis and already in search of legitimacy if not recognition, Alexander Zverev was annoyed on Wednesday at having to justify that he is not a world number one by default, after his elimination at the Masters 1000 in Paris.

Published on: 04/11/2026 - 21:53

The German's accession to the world throne, thanks in particular to his first two Grand Slam titles this season, has sparked comments that are not always laudatory in the specialist press, sometimes describing the 30th world number one since 1973 as "lucky", "undeserving", "by default" or a "trompe l'oeil".

Main reason: to win at Roland-Garros and the US Open, Zverev did not have to beat the two ogres of the circuit Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz. And when the Italian and the Spaniard were not diminished or injured, they respectively blocked his path in the semi-final at the Australian Open and in the final at Wimbledon.

“I feel like I'm the only world number one in the history of tennis who has to explain why it's normal for me to be world number one. I think I deserve to be where I am, even if I lost today,” breathed the Hamburg colossus, after his defeat against Lorenzo Musetti.

“I don’t think anyone has ever had to justify themselves so much,” he insisted, quite upset.

Zverev has long held the reputation of the best player in history never to have won a Major, after three lost finals (New York 2020, Paris 2024 and Melbourne 2025).

But even if he broke the glass ceiling this year, he has so far only won three victories in twelve matches against players in the top 10. A ratio (25%) well below those of Alcaraz (17-4) and Sinner (19-4) in 2025.

For Musetti, the German has been "the most consistent player of all" this season and therefore deserves to be at the top of the ATP rankings.

“New dimension”

Same story from Boris Becker, the last German before "Sascha" crowned Grand Slam -- in 1996 at the Australian Open -- who finds it unfair to minimize the performances of his compatriot.

"To win a Grand Slam tournament, you have to win seven best-of-five matches in 14 days. It's extremely difficult, almost no matter who you play against," he argued in the weekly Der Spiegel.

Zverev, who has undertaken a lot of work on himself to avoid reproducing bloody shots, like in Acapulco in 2022 when he hit the referee's chair with his racket, conversely suffers from a sometimes seemingly nonchalant attitude, which would betray a persistent mental feverishness.

“When I see him play, I see someone who plays much too passively, much too defensively in decisive moments,” analyzed the Swiss Roger Federer, winner of 20 Grand Slam titles, in 2024.

But this "small window" of opportunity, without Alcaraz and Sinner, allowed him to take on a "new dimension" with two titles likely to definitively "liberate" him, anticipates Guy Forget, former world No.4.

“At Roland-Garros and at the US Open in particular, we saw a player who was more confident, more offensive, directing the exchanges more,” underlines the captain of the Blues from 1999 to 2012.

“Abnegation”

Less popular on and off the courts, even in Germany, than his two younger rivals, Zverev should "open up a little more" believes Becker. “I have met him privately, he has charm, he is funny, he is correct. But perhaps he does not consider that important enough.”

However, his record would make many blush: in addition to his two Majors, the German has won everything, or almost, with 26 titles including Olympic gold in Tokyo and two Masters at the end of the season.

His atypical journey, too, should arouse a certain empathy, particularly the fact of being such a champion while being diabetic, underlines to AFP Cédric Pioline, director of the Masters 1000 in Paris.

“Each time, he has this strength to get up when he takes a blow, get up and still continue to go to work, it is still remarkable this self-sacrifice which inhabits him”, pleads the former world No.5 (2000).

“In five or ten years, no one will say that he won without beating Alcaraz or Sinner. The opportunity presented itself, he seized it,” continues Pioline.

The main person concerned said he was "impatient" to compete against the two former world No. 1s "in full health", from January 2027 in Melbourne.

© 2026 AFP

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.