After the debacle in the midterms, Donald Trump and the Republicans agree in attributing the electoral disaster to the war in Iran and the economic impact on Americans. Within the party, however, several point the finger directly at the president, while he seeks to distance himself from the defeat. Trump defends that "it was worth it" to open the conflict, but potentially presidential figures, such as J. D. Vance, Marco Rubio or Ron DeSantis, try to distance themselves.
First modification: 05/11/2026 - 23:56
"The reason we lost is the war... If you want to argue that it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next six years was worth it, then do it." This is how J.D. expressed himself. Vance, the vice president of the United States, after the defeat of the Republicans in the midterms of November 3, in which the Democrats remained in control of both houses of Congress.
Vance, who is being considered as one of the main Republican cards for the 2028 presidential elections, thus sought to distance himself not only from the collapse in the elections, but also from Donald Trump's decisions on the war in Iran and its aftermath.
For his part, Trump admits that the war in Iran caused the Republican fall, but insists that it was worth it. "Yes, I believe it. Yes," he responded to the press on Wednesday. “If I had to do it again, I would do it again because in the long term it is the only answer (…) Iran cannot be allowed to have a nuclear weapon.”
To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.
An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.
Professor Osamah Khalil, director of the International Relations Program at Syracuse University, believes that what Vance seeks, if he fails to change Trump's position on the war, "is to at least mark some distance from that policy when he runs for president in the 2028 elections."
"The 2026 midterm elections in the US represented a resounding rejection of President Trump's policies during his second term, in particular the war with Iran. Vance's statement indicates that sectors of the Government that want a negotiated solution to end the conflict as soon as possible are trying to use the results of the midterm elections to influence President Trump," the expert tells France 24 en Español.
"But, if that fails, Vance will at least be able to mark some distance from that policy with a view to the presidential elections," emphasizes Khalil, also a historian specializing in US foreign relations and the modern Middle East.
Other analysts agree that Vance's statement is an attempt to move away from an unpopular policy and begin to shape his own path ahead of the 2028 presidential election. Critics, for their part, point to a "disloyal" stance.
“Frankly, it was disloyal to the president (...) The only thing I heard was: 'We lost because of the war with Iran'...“(Trump) says it was the right thing to do. Why does your vice president say something different? Because he wants to run for President,” Marc Thiessen, a conservative political commentator, told the 'Fox' network.
Read also: Who will pay for the defeat?: The internal struggle intensifies in the Republican Party after the midterms
The two Republican shores against Trump
Vance and Trump's statements reaffirm the existence of two sides in the Republican Party.
On the one hand, there are those who, like Vance, aim to abandon foreign interventionism, and traditional Republicans, supporters of a tough international policy and regime change in Iran, for example.
But for voters, the course should be along four axes. According to a post by the vice president: "end the war in Iran, focus on the cost of living and inflation, prioritize US interests, and change the relationship with Israel."
However, within the more traditional line, voices like that of Ari Fleischer, spokesperson for the White House in the George W. Bush government, consider that the problem was not the war, but stopping the offensive in the middle of it. This is what he responded to Vance:
"Sir, Vice President: Let me present a different perspective. The problem was not the war in Iran. It was the ceasefire. If you start a war, you must win it and end it; otherwise, don't start it," Fleischer said on X.
To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.
The American president himself dismissed any responsibility for his party's defeat in the midterms. According to him, the Republicans would have won easily if he had been on the ballot.
Donald Trump's analysis of the results is "ridiculous," questioned Jason Roe, a Republican strategist from Michigan interviewed by 'The New York Times'. For him, the president is, on the contrary, "the architect of the collapse" of the party.
Under these views, "within the Republican Party there is growing uncertainty about the direction it should take," declared Matt Dole, local president of the party in Licking County, Ohio, to the 'Politico' media.
"President Trump's MAGA movement has also been divided over the wars in Iran and Gaza, as well as relations with Israel. These tensions can be expected to intensify during the final two years of Trump's presidency and extend into the 2028 campaign," Khalil predicts.
Read alsoIran mocks Trump's electoral setback: "They talked about a regime change, we made it happen"
A race to 2028 away from Trump?
The midterm elections, with a Congress now controlled by Democrats, now give way to the 2028 race for the Presidency, in which Donald Trump cannot run.
In addition to Vance, a possible Republican deck includes the current head of US diplomacy, Marco Rubio, and the outgoing governor of Florida, Ron DeSantis, who also preliminarily point to a distance from Trump, in the midst of an exchange of blame for the result of the midterms.
In this regard, Dick Wadhams, a Republican consultant from Colorado, explains that most of the candidates who lost key Senate races in conservative states were chosen or endorsed by the president. "It was not a vote in favor of the Democrats," he told The New York Times. "It was a vote against Trump."
Along these lines, according to the British newspaper 'The Independent', Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who unsuccessfully sought the Republican presidential nomination in 2016, would be considering leaving office to distance himself from Trump before launching his candidacy. That version was described by the State Department as fake news.
Regarding Rubio's potential candidacy, Newt Gingrich, former Republican speaker of the House of Representatives, noted that the party's primaries are "completely open" after Tuesday's result and that the number of people who prefer the current Secretary of State over Vance "is impressive."
For his part, the outgoing governor of Florida, Ron DeSantis, who unsuccessfully contested with Donald Trump for the Republican candidacy in 2024, also seems to be moving discreetly, but throwing darts.
Commenting on the loss of ground in the midterms, DeSantis lamented that the Democrats' margin of victory will make it difficult for Republicans to regain control of Congress in 2028.
"We may not have any chance of regaining control of the Senate until 2032," the Republican added.
And as for the 2028 presidential election, he commented: "There will be aspects of Trump that Republicans will want to emulate, but if the public demands a different course on certain issues, then the question of compromise will arise. If you take different positions, I think Trump will probably have harsh words for you in Truth Social. (...) Will the 2028 elections be the choice for continuity, another Trump term, or the choice for change?"
For Ron DeSantis, the solution is to maintain some of Trump's legacy while at the same time daring to make changes on certain issues.
In the wake of the midterm elections, Republican heavyweights have been critical and yet subtle, but the shadow message is perfectly clear: after ten years of Trumpism, it is time for the party to redefine itself and find its new voice.
"President Trump has entered the 'lame duck' stage, with historically low popularity ratings and an uneasy stalemate with Iran that contributed to his crushing defeat at the polls. If he hopes to salvage the last two years of his presidency and his legacy, as well as maintain the MAGA movement, it is essential, first, that he quickly end the war with Iran," Khalil closes.
Read also: What's next for the Trump Government after the Democrats' victory in the midterms?
With Reuters, EFE, AP and local media
Related keywords
The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.




